* All sociologist jobs are government jobs? Citation needed.
* Dangerous low pay jobs are the result of public education system? This model lacks explanatory power. There have always been low-pay dangerous jobs. These occur in times and places where there is no public education system. They occur in times and places where there is a public education system. They occur in proportions (as related to other available jobs) that seem unrelated to the existence of teacher unions. Rather they seem to be a function of economic development level, with a healthy mix of labor law based restrictions.
Essentially, this rant seems to be off topic soap boxing. Given the "green" username - probably some form of sock-puppetry.
They said that the going rate for a single 12 hour weekend overtime shift was $2350 and that some of their "young lads" could clear 125k in a year. This is around 4 times the UK Median wage.
Miners in Australia also could command a very good wage
The sociologist in the article - getting paid over 120k. Read the article before jumping with rage.
Basic economics - the low pay is a result of oversupply of people willing to do the work. The oversupply is because many uneducated men being churned out from k12. k12 is run by teachers.
I'm quite sure you're a teacher or your parents were teacher, that explains the rage (By the way, one of my parents was a teacher, but I'm not going to use that to excuse the system).
The model you are proposing has great post-hoc explanatory powers within the united states - however it does not appear to have predictive powers over what we will find in other places and times. Therefore I question it's validity, until you can show how the same model applies to other situations, and can show exigent factors that are relevant when it doesn't apply. Again, this is not rage - this is merely not accepting an insufficiently explained model at face value.
FWIW (not that it matters): I am a software engineer/programmer, my parents are in sales and HR, my other family members are not in education either. I just think overly simple explanations should always be questioned.
As for the salary of a government worker - that depends on the job they do, the value they create etc. I don't know the details to make blanket statements. I think there is a tradeoff - good people doing the job requires competitive salary, paying bad salaries is generally more expensive as it requires more workers to do the same job.
The models are pretty simple - they are called supply and demand. They work for everything else in economics. Low pay for dangerous work is not so exceptional situation.
In poorer countries, there is even less pay for even more dangerous work, because education is even worse there. There's a few data points there.
And there's quite a lot of literature on the education system and teacher unions. To start off with their's Waiting For Superman (2010).
As for the attempt to derail over "politeness concerns" because I used the word rant - I won't bite.
By the way, very few of your comments have data backing them up, and often are just simple 'models' with some variables you wrote down mixed in with rudeness to other commenters.
I am merely requesting more information on your claims.
The low-paying dangerous occupations are only that way because there's so many foolish men to take them up.
And you can blame the education system for turning out those foolish men - so a lot of that can be directly blamed on the corrupt teaching unions - whose main interest is in increasing pay and lowering work requirements.
This is where edu startups can come in and help society while earning money.
- Retrain the low pay workers into web designers and app developers. Gamify the education system and make profits by selling high-scoring students to corps that need them.
- Disrupt the teachers union with apps and websites that allow people to form ad-hoc schools outside the system - homeschooling 2.0.
As PG says - kill hollywood and kill government education.