Re:On Hyperloop
by robomartin on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:15PM
(#6240545)
> So what about SpaceX and Tesla? To me those indicate that Musk must be a pretty decent engineer, and perhaps more importantly, must be excellent at leading real hardcore engineers in complex domains.
Well, then, how do you explain the following?
1- Thermal expansion and contraction issues diametrically
opposed to what happens in the real world
2- Proposing that an entire 300 or 400 mile tube be a single
welded solid tube with no turns or incremental expansion
gaps. Really? In the real world? Along the 5 freeway?
3- Grotesquely underestimating seismic effects
4- Estimating a cost at least one order of magnitude
lower than what it will actually be in the real world
5- Not taking a drive down the Golden State highway before proposing
that columns be installed every 100 feet to support the tubes.
No, really, go on Google Maps and take the drive yourself.
I think these guys thought it would be a cool and possibly marketing-worthy thing to put out something like this. They put a little time into it here and there and, per the paper, a short amount of full time effort. They were probably so focused on the tube transport physics that they neglected to connect to the real world.
At some level I don't fault them for putting this out. They are obviously far more focused on building cars and rockets and that's exactly how it should be. If what came out was a fully engineered project it would have meant that they took valuable time away from Tesla and SpaceX to apply on this thing. That could border on being a breach of fiduciary duty.
At this point I am going to mark this off as science fiction simply because I am now convinced it cannot be built outside of a super-expensive short range test installation.
Well, then, how do you explain the following?
Start here: http://goo.gl/maps/zPPKaI think these guys thought it would be a cool and possibly marketing-worthy thing to put out something like this. They put a little time into it here and there and, per the paper, a short amount of full time effort. They were probably so focused on the tube transport physics that they neglected to connect to the real world.
At some level I don't fault them for putting this out. They are obviously far more focused on building cars and rockets and that's exactly how it should be. If what came out was a fully engineered project it would have meant that they took valuable time away from Tesla and SpaceX to apply on this thing. That could border on being a breach of fiduciary duty.
At this point I am going to mark this off as science fiction simply because I am now convinced it cannot be built outside of a super-expensive short range test installation.