> To say, as this correspondent did, that "engineering isn't about first principles", is to argue that it has nothing to do with science
It is not arguing, as you claimed, that the disciplines or "independent of each other and of physics", especially not when, as that correspondent did, an acknowledgement is included in the same sentence which expressly acknowledges the fact (while dismissing its relevance in context) that they all derive from the same physical laws.
No one is arguing that different engineering disciplines aren't related to each other and to physics; the debate is about the extent to which how those relations (as well as Musk's connection to certain engineering disciplines through SpaceX and Tesla) are relevant in the context of the Hyperloop proposal, the criticism of it, and the treatment of Musk as an authority deserving special deference in regard to that proposal.
It is not arguing, as you claimed, that the disciplines or "independent of each other and of physics", especially not when, as that correspondent did, an acknowledgement is included in the same sentence which expressly acknowledges the fact (while dismissing its relevance in context) that they all derive from the same physical laws.
No one is arguing that different engineering disciplines aren't related to each other and to physics; the debate is about the extent to which how those relations (as well as Musk's connection to certain engineering disciplines through SpaceX and Tesla) are relevant in the context of the Hyperloop proposal, the criticism of it, and the treatment of Musk as an authority deserving special deference in regard to that proposal.