Reading past the usual academic exaggeration (where everything is "promising" and "has potential"), the data is underwhelming -- there's no clear indication that pagerank has an advantage over traditional citation metrics.
Here's a Google cache link to a paper that discusses some of the things I was talking about (i.e. how the metaphor breaks down when moving from web to journals):
http://www.jneurosci.org/cgi/content/full/28/44/11103
Reading past the usual academic exaggeration (where everything is "promising" and "has potential"), the data is underwhelming -- there's no clear indication that pagerank has an advantage over traditional citation metrics.
Here's a Google cache link to a paper that discusses some of the things I was talking about (i.e. how the metaphor breaks down when moving from web to journals):
http://74.125.155.132/search?q=cache:KdKSGivmckgJ:www.cais-a...
As I said, there have been lots of other papers. I don't recall seeing one that made a convincing case, but I'm certainly not an expert....