* Redefining SF and LA to Hayward and Sylmar allows the Musk proposal to make an extremely unfair trip time comparison, and, moreover, Musk's proposal can't easily do a "real" SF and LA because unlike HSR the Hyperloop can't repurpose infrastructure.
* At the speeds and course plotting Musk alludes to, the Hyperloop will make its passengers very motion sick.
* The costs Musk projects are unrealistic; for instance, if the Hyperloop can really construct elevated tracks at 1/10th the per-mile cost of existing viaducts, that cost improvement alone would be an equally important advance. Similar problems exist for the tunneling cost projections, and are exacerbated by the fact that a realistic course for the Hyperloop would probably require even more tunneling than projected.
http://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/08/13/loopy...
From this article:
* Redefining SF and LA to Hayward and Sylmar allows the Musk proposal to make an extremely unfair trip time comparison, and, moreover, Musk's proposal can't easily do a "real" SF and LA because unlike HSR the Hyperloop can't repurpose infrastructure.
* At the speeds and course plotting Musk alludes to, the Hyperloop will make its passengers very motion sick.
* The costs Musk projects are unrealistic; for instance, if the Hyperloop can really construct elevated tracks at 1/10th the per-mile cost of existing viaducts, that cost improvement alone would be an equally important advance. Similar problems exist for the tunneling cost projections, and are exacerbated by the fact that a realistic course for the Hyperloop would probably require even more tunneling than projected.
There's a good MeFi thread on this too.