News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by RyanZAG on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:47AM (#6236661)
I was with him all the way until "The ruling class has figured out that a happy and productive population with free time on their hands is a mortal danger". The author does make the point that it might also be the people themselves pushing for it, at least.

The 'ruling class' really doesn't care if anybody is or isn't working pointless jobs. Society as a whole is forcing people into pointless jobs by viewing anybody who is unemployed as some kind of failure. When a child gets out of school they need to find work or they have failed. If someone has no job their perceived lack of purpose ultimately pushes them into mental illness, drug abuses or even suicide. This has nothing to do with someone forcing people to work and everything to do with the human brain's need for purpose forcing working - even if that work is pointless. For example, you often hear someone say with pride how they have worked so much they don't have time to eat or sleep even when the work they are doing is something like filling out pointless bureaucratic paperwork.

"How can one even begin to speak of dignity in labour when one secretly feels one’s job should not exist?"

Most people in these kind of jobs actually believe that the job is necessary. Especially in academic and administrative disciplines the very thought of their work not being useful will have most people very defensive and angry. They'll probably go as far as to sabotage genuine useful production in an effort to prove their value.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by cabalamat on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:43AM (#6236876)
> Most people in these kind of jobs actually believe that the job is necessary.

Really? Or do they secretly worry that it isn't?

> Especially in academic and administrative disciplines the very thought of their work not being useful will have most people very defensive and angry.

"No one gets in trouble for saying that 2 + 2 is 5, or that people in Pittsburgh are ten feet tall. Such obviously false statements might be treated as jokes, or at worst as evidence of insanity, but they are not likely to make anyone mad. The statements that make people mad are the ones they worry might be believed. I suspect the statements that make people maddest are those they worry might be true." -- PG, http://www.paulgraham.com/say.html

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by kybernetikos on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:20AM (#6237025)
While a pithy thing to say with some truth in it, I have experienced people asserting things of the order of 2 + 2 = 5, and given the right situation it can have the potential to make people pretty mad.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by solistice on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:57AM (#6237219)
Which is why they revoked your math license, we know the story.

No, when you say 2 + 2 = 5, you can put it off as "He can't be serious", and then it's off your mind. But if the person keeps asserting it till you can't brush it off anymore, that's when heads tend to roll. It goes against what you believe, and subconsciously, that goes against you as a person.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by CamperBob2 on Monday August 19, 2013 @03:22PM (#6239130)
To paraphrase a famous xkcd strip, "2+2 = 5" isn't funny anymore when it's being stated by a US Congressman.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by eli_gottlieb on Monday August 19, 2013 @02:58PM (#6238945)
I've certainly caught myself doing this.

Of course, that means nothing other than that I'm dumb sometimes, which was a known fact.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by beat on Monday August 19, 2013 @11:46AM (#6237850)
The concept that everyone must have a "job" (that is, work for someone else for a wage) is deep in the psyche of both the ruling class and the majority, so both reinforce it through culture and propaganda. It's no different from how previous societies believed that Jews controlled the banks, or children got sick and died because they were suffocated in their sleep by witches. It's rank idiocy, but it's rank idiocy that almost everyone believes.

Ever read The Emperor's New Clothes?

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @08:01PM (#6247398)
Regarding those theories about the Jews... what do you mean, previous societies? Lots of people today actually, really believe that the faults of capitalism come from Jewish finance.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by vanderZwan on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:55AM (#6236688)
> The author does make the point that it might also be the people themselves pushing for it, at least.

I think the implication is that that is largely a form of Stockholm syndrome.

> They'll probably go as far as to sabotage genuine useful production in an effort to prove their value.

How is this not an extra argument in favour of his claim that there are lots of bullshit jobs out there?

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by RyanZAG on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:00AM (#6236706)
"How is this not an extra argument in favour of his claim that there are lots of bullshit jobs out there?"

I was not arguing against the idea of bullshit jobs. It's not even possible to argue against that! I was arguing against the reason for having bullshit jobs. He attributes this to some plan by 'the man' to put people in these jobs. I'm arguing it is people putting themselves in these jobs by themselves.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by JonnieCache on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:17AM (#6236780)
>He attributes this to some plan by 'the man' to put people in these jobs. I'm arguing it is people putting themselves in these jobs by themselves.

Those two things are not mutually exclusive. See the last line of the article:

"Clearly, the system was never consciously designed. It emerged from almost a century of trial and error."

People in power make little daily nudges, those under the yoke follow the path of least resistance, and society wanders towards an equilibrium.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by RyanZAG on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:33AM (#6236845)
Alright, I understand the argument now, thank you.

I still disagree that anybody is trying to make this occur through nudges, a plan or any sort of action - considered or not. I believe it is the result of human kind's base urge to find meaning in themselves and their lives. I'd say that even if people in power were to try and push people into jobs, the people being pushed out of jobs would seek to find any job they could do regardless of how useless it may be. Simply to be doing a job and satisfying themselves.

I fully accept it's a plausible argument that people in control are pushing us, though.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by JonnieCache on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:41AM (#6236873)
It's a bit more than a just plausible argument. There's a whole cabinet department devoted to it:

http://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/sep/09/cameron-nudge...

https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/behavioural-insi...

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by RyanZAG on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:22AM (#6237038)
I'm still not convinced. The attempt by one government to carry out 'economic nudging' does not mean that the nudging has had any real effect. There is also the problem that countries without such attempts (eh.. Sri Lanka?) are having any different results in people working bullshit jobs.

Again, the argument is plausible but is a long way from being compelling, for me at least. The simplest answer - that people are doing what they do because it's how people work - is far more compelling for me. The right answer is usually the one that passes the 'least surprise' test the best.

What would surprise you more?

  1. A group of the government and wealththy individuals
     are managing to convince the entire population into
     working bullshit jobs.

  2. People without jobs don't feel they have a purpose
     and try to create a purpose in any way they can,
     such as copying those who do appear to have a purpose.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by JonnieCache on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:49AM (#6237165)
I don't think we really disagree. People act in their own interest, and for those with power over others, those self interested acts are inevitably going to influence the lives of those in their power.

To me, it is least surprising that these acts would take the form of subtle "nudges," carried out through the media, education system, etc. There doesn't have to be a big scary plan behind it, it's just the cumulative effect of many powerful actors trying to maintain and increase their power.

My reference to the government's "Nudge Unit" (worst rap crew ever) was mainly to illustrate the fact that this is seen as an effective and sensible mode of exercising power by the 21st century establishment. They tried various forms of more overt, coercive control in the last century and it didn't work out so well. Hence I am least surprised that they are now doing the same thing through more layers of abstraction.

But yeah, I'm certainly not saying I absolutely believe all of this to be true, with tinfoil certainty. It's just that like many others around here, I've started looking at current events less in isolation and more through the lens of post WW2 history, and it certainly throws some things into sharper relief. Let's hope I'm not just staring at Rorschach blots.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by LOSindignados on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:44AM (#6237136)
RyanZAG, I suspect it's more a matter of it being convenient for those with entrenched wealth and power to let the masses struggle for the scraps they have left over. This situation leads most of us to compete for the bullshit jobs, to get angry at those who were fortunate enough to get real jobs (even if they are poorly compensated relative to their social value, e.g. teachers), and to generally be so distracted by the charade as to not notice the massive fraud taking place behind doors forever closed to their unwashed, foolish selves.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by eli_gottlieb on Monday August 19, 2013 @02:59PM (#6238951)
Actually, I would be far more surprised by (2). I don't know anyone who actually believes that employment is their "purpose".
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by singingfish on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:17AM (#6236774)
Thus "the man" influences the people to act against their own best interest. Happens all the time.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by impendia on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:50AM (#6236673)
I was with you until the end.

Can you provide an example of an academic sabotaging useful production in order to prove his or her value?

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by RyanZAG on Monday August 19, 2013 @07:58AM (#6236702)
That happens less in academics - I was thinking more of administrative areas in corporations. For example, there are no shortages of stories of administrators in procurement adding in additional required paperwork when more efficient computerized systems make their stamp on documents less required.

Actually, this has happened in academics in a way too - consider the requirement of ever lengthening literature reviews in PHD theses. These have come about because of the ease of access to academic documents through digitized journals making libraries and supervisors less valuable. The answer is to increase their value by increasing the amount of work required so that they will still be necessary to wade through it. I'm not sure how much this is sabotage and not just the result of electronic journals making this easier though, which is why the example in the paragraph above is far more relevant.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by impendia on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:11AM (#6236749)
I am a math professor. This phenomenon of lengthening literature reviews doesn't exist in math, nor indeed have I ever seen mathematicians assign pointless busywork to sabotage others, or to inflate our own importance, or for any other reason.

Indeed, we hate extraneous paperwork:

http://www.mathjobs.org/jobs

and are trying to change the library system:

http://thecostofknowledge.com/

Now the intrinsic value of research math as a whole may be debated, especially that of the bottom 90% of researchers (and I would not say I'm in the top 10%).

But I have really not observed math professors to be guilty of what you claim. Quite frankly, math itself is hard enough; there's no point in setting additional hoops for students to jump through. It would just make us look foolish, and waste our own time (in addition to that of others).

I can't speak for other disciplines.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by bennyg on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:53AM (#6236919)
Well, pointless busywork was a staple of my high school and under days of math. Once I got to college, I had a professor for Calculus I that said our grade was the four tests + the final or just the final - whichever grade was higher. Having taken Cal in high school, I just showed up for the final and got a B+ (I reversed the damn derivatives of ln/e).

That was the best math class I never took. To be fair, my discipline wasn't anything scientific so needing math wasn't in my college curriculum (switched from business to psychology then to art and advertising). I took another class, Discrete Math, from the same teacher my senior year as an elective and absolutely loved it. I never skipped a day.

He was a great teacher, and the way his class was set up for grading and not really giving a shit about homework was perfect. If I were to ever teach math later, his format would be how I would do it.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by jdpage on Monday August 19, 2013 @12:36PM (#6238113)
"Math professor" probably means at the college or university level -- high school math is widely regarded as complete and utter BS.

I've taken... a rather significant pile of maths classes at this point (I'm majoring in it), and I've never felt like any of the college-level maths classes assigned busywork. I may not have liked the size of the workload (oh god, real analysis), but I've never felt it was unreasonable.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by ramchip on Monday August 19, 2013 @11:00AM (#6237560)
I think you're interpreting "math professor" as "school teacher", while others are talking about the tenured kind of professors. "Students" here are researchers, who do work potentially ostensibly for society, not just homework for their own education.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by Spooky23 on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:15AM (#6236771)
I worked at a government agency that circa 2005 was using paper timesheets. The timesheets were required to be printed on a specific shade of blue paper.

Hilarity ensued when some admin ordered "air force blue" paper instead of "power blue". The HR director decreed that only "power blue" would be accepted, and all other hues would be rejected. They probably spent 200 hours debating it.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by protomyth on Monday August 19, 2013 @11:15AM (#6237658)
Ok, I got to ask what exactly was HR's explanation for a particular shade of blue?

I've been part of something like this is a weird way. In the summer the humidity got too much for our HP4 printer and it would crinkle 20lb paper and get jammed. We found the 28 or 32 lb paper (long time ago / cannot remember exactly) would not jam and the printer worked fine.

So, in the summer, we changed to ordering the thicker paper. The gold paper was cheaper than the white paper at that weight. So, we order gold paper every summer.

Long after the building had air conditioning and the old printer was replaced, they still ordered gold paper every summer until the program closed.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by roel_v on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:13AM (#6236762)
" consider the requirement of ever lengthening literature reviews in PHD theses. These have come about because of the ease of access to academic documents through digitized journals making libraries and supervisors less valuable."

I'm not sure I understand your conspiracy theory mumbo jumbo correctly, but I cannot help but take from this that you are saying that because finding literature has become faster due to electronic access to papers, the added value of the Phd supervisor has gone down. If this is so, you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about, a position for which I find additional evidence in your use of 'PHD' with all capitals which nobody in academia would do. Look, if you have something valuable to add to the discussion, please do; but if you're just going to make things up to fit your ideological predispositions, stay on Reddit.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by jclos on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:32AM (#6236839)
I agree. If anything, the explosion of digital libraries and thus of available information would tend to make librarians and supervisors with deep domain knowledge even more essential to sort through all the noise.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by eli_gottlieb on Monday August 19, 2013 @03:03PM (#6238983)
If I had to guess, literature reviews are getting longer because us researchers are quickly going through the lower-hanging fruit and thus reaching discoveries that have more and more "dependencies".
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by olefoo on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:06AM (#6236729)
Derrida.

And I'm only sort of being facetious. Sometime in the 1980's the humanities seemed to collectively decide that 'theory' was more important than the ability to think and communicate clearly. To my mind this has always been the point at which Academia as a class abdicated it's responsibilities to society at large in favor of internal power games and obscurantism.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by impendia on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:14AM (#6236765)
Ah, but this trend was fought by another academic. Alan Sokal, NYU physicist, famously completely bullshitted an essay and got it published by Social Text, a leading postmodern sociology journal.

http://www.physics.nyu.edu/sokal/

Scroll down to "Transgressing the Boundaries".

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by ronaldx on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:18AM (#6236782)
I assume you are an academic - therefore, I imagine you have heard of cases where a peer reviewer killed an article just because it contradicted the reviewer's own work?

Even if an academic is not explicitly sabotaging work, it's clear from the amount of time spent on grant applications and general bureaucracy that their useful production is being sabotaged.

To meet bureaucratic standards, researchers are often required to teach and educators are often required to publish... it's not effective production.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by lsh on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:09AM (#6236990)
> I assume you are an academic - therefore, I imagine you have heard of cases where a peer reviewer killed an article just because it contradicted the reviewer's own work?

Thats why you have the reviewers declare no conflict of interest, have more than one peer reviewer and an editor who makes the final decision and assigns further peer reviewers if necessary.

I agree with your last two points.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by ronaldx on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:47AM (#6237152)
> have more than one peer reviewer and an editor who makes the final decision and assigns further peer reviewers if necessary.

QED.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by ZeroGravitas on Monday August 19, 2013 @09:36AM (#6237088)
The continued existence of lecturing, 4 decades or more after it's been shown to be a poor use of time?

An article I recently read (written only 30 years ago) attributed a lot of this to the academic's ego enjoying the feel of being an expert, when a printed sheet of paper, written by someone else would have a bigger impact on the students attending the lecture.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by halo on Monday August 19, 2013 @10:47AM (#6237501)
It seems self-evident that lecturing is a hugely inefficient and ineffective way of teaching people.

But I don't think it's about stroking the academic's ego as much as maintaining academic jobs. Remove the unnecessarily labour-intensive lecturing component and, unfortunately, it's far harder to justify large state subsidies and tuition fees that pay for universities. Universities are strongly incentivised to continue lecturing busy-work.

I would also guess that while lectures themselves are horrible, the structures, routines and environments created around lecturing are extremely valuable to students. You can't replace lectures with nothing. That's why MOOCs and textbooks, for all their virtues, are not an adequate replacement.

Even so, I've long wished someone would invest in creating videos that present university-level lecture material with television production values. I think you could create a format that is far more engaging and memorable than the typical lecture, you could have hosts with presentation and communication skills rather than academics, and a team of writers with expertise in the subject and education could spend time doing research to find the best way of teaching a subject and ensuring clarity, accuracy and understanding. Why not have Calculus II with Ryan Seacrest?

(Note: this is completely layman speculation)

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by davidvaughan on Monday August 19, 2013 @01:54PM (#6238575)
"It seems self-evident that lecturing is a hugely inefficient and ineffective way of teaching people."

Is it possible that only poor lecturers give hugely inefficient and ineffective lectures?

It seems to me the point of lectures isn't to transmit information - that can be done using a book. Rather it is, or ought to be, a demonstration of how a master deals with a problem or answers a question.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by keithpeter on Monday August 19, 2013 @10:17AM (#6237327)
Depends on level.

I teach basic maths to adults and teenagers (the latter tend to be the ones at the back of the class in compulsory education). One of my big projects in the first part of the year (before the exams loom over the horizon) is to encourage students to read the textbook themselves. In the rare classes where this becomes accepted, I can use the lessons more like seminars and get the students moved up the problem solving ladder.

Given that we have had reliable maths textbooks since around 1215, and printed ones since roughly 1580, the difficulty of achieving this always surprises me.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by nbouscal on Monday August 19, 2013 @01:32PM (#6238438)
1215? What's wrong with Euclid?
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by keithpeter on Monday August 19, 2013 @02:14PM (#6238700)
Well, ok, I was thinking of arithmetic and algorithmic methods in number. I'll let you have Euclid, although it would be heavy going now to use that as a textbook...
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by nbouscal on Monday August 19, 2013 @02:26PM (#6238758)
It's only been about a century since it was fair to assume that every educated person had read it. I think the fact that we wouldn't be able to use it as a textbook in schools today is a really bad sign.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by keithpeter on Monday August 19, 2013 @04:23PM (#6239541)
Er - not so sure about Euclid being read widely as recently as 1913. Definitions of 'educated person' were very narrow then in England. 'Mechanics institutes' taught 'practical mechanics' far more than abstract geometry to working people.

Euclid is a small part of mathematics, although a powerful example of logical reasoning. If I could encourage my Level 2 students to a level where they could read and understand (say) Chapter 8 of Silver's The Signal and The Noise we might be getting somewhere.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by dalke on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @05:07PM (#6246574)
(Yes, this is part II. I got interested in the topic.)

I empathize with the difficulty of defining 'educated person.' As you rightly point out, there are different threads in what an "education" means. http://www.educationengland.org.uk/history/chapter03.html goes into the three main groups - 'public educators', 'industrial trainers', and 'old humanists' - which participated in that debate, ending "The curriculum which evolved during the 19th century was 'a compromise between all three groups, but with the industrial trainers predominant' (Williams 1961:142). This was 'damaging both to general education and to the new kinds of vocational training' (Williams 1961:143).

For purposes of this discussion, I think it's reasonable to refine the meaning of "educated person" specifically to "expected from someone who has graduated from a liberal arts college." I think this definition works for most of the last 500 years of having liberal arts colleges, up until the mid-1900s.

My definition specifically excludes religious and industrial education, which I think is appropriate for the intent.

Now, I noted that the Elements book I pointed to was meant for "elementary" students. I think that means up to age 12 or so. It's definitely no later than what the 1868 Taunton Report proposed:

> first-grade schools with a leaving age of 18 or 19 would provide a 'liberal education' - including Latin and Greek - to prepare upper and upper-middle class boys for the universities and the older professions;

(vs. second- and third-grade educations meant for the middle classes and lower.)

So the two pieces of evidence I have, for why someone in 1913 with a liberal arts education (an 'educated person') would have likely studied the Elements is first, the two forewords for a text book meant for 'elementary' students, and second, the number of reprintings of the text book, which implies that many were published.

I can now add more data points. In "THE RIVER WAR: An Account of the Reconquest of the Sudan" by Winston S. Churchill, 1902 edition, from http://www.gutenberg.org/files/4943/4943-h/4943-h.htm :

> The whole journey by rail from Merawi to Dakhesh occupied four days, whereas General Hunter with his flying column had taken eight—a fact which proves that, in certain circumstances which Euclid could not have foreseen, two sides of a triangle are together shorter than the third side.

Why would Churchill use this reference if the readers, educated in the mid- to late-1800s, are not expected to understand it?

There was a big debate in the UK in and around 1902 about the teaching of Euclid.

In Google Scholar's preview for "SOME RECENT DISCUSSION ON THE TEACHING OF MATHEMATICS", WW Beman - School Science and Mathematics, 1903 - Wiley Online Library "I may add that the address was given in full in the Educational Review for February, 1902. This discussion of the teaching of mathematics in England particularly with regard to the retention of Euclid as a test-book of geometry is by no means a new one." See also a letter in Nature http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1902Natur..66..103S pointing out that Schopenhauer was also critical. And a 1903 Nature followup at http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1903Natur..68R...7P saying "I WILL not deny that some reformers desire to abolish Euclid and establish another sequence of propositions in abstract geometry for schoolboys .. Two per cent. of schoolboys take to abstract reasoning as ducks take to water, and they ought not to be discouraged from the study of Euclid, but they and all the other boys ought to study geometry experimentally, logic entering into the study just as it enters into other parts of experimental physics. If the best modern books have a fault, it lies in the absurd assumption that an experimental sequence ought to have some connection with the Euclidean sequence."

In http://www.jstor.org/discover/10.2307/3603959?uid=3738984&ui... I read a page from a 1901 paper for the Mathematical Gazette (London) saying "(ii) The question of the retention of Euclid as a text-book was again raised. It was urged with considerable force that our retention of a book discarded by other nations had at any rate a presumption against it, and that it was wrong to sacrifice the interests of education to the east of the examiner. (iii) More than one speaker pointed out that if the experimental or intuitional method of introducing the truths of Mathematics, and especially of Geometry, were used from the lowest classes of our schools upwards, the strictly deductive course would not lose but gain in effectiveness."

So, it looks like the end of the 1800s was the death-knell for Euclid's Elements, but it was in the UK where it hung around the longest, perhaps for another 20 years.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by dalke on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @03:54PM (#6246115)
Hard to say if it was "widely read", but the Elements was certainly read by Lincoln in the mid-1800s.

This text book of the Elements was first published in 1888, updated in 1900, and with reprints every year or two until (at least) 1915 http://openlibrary.org/books/OL24198679M/Text-book_of_Euclid....

I'll agree with thesis that it wasn't uncommon about 100 years ago as a standard text, and agree that that was about when it stopped being common.

If you read the preface to the 1888 version, you'll see: "From first to last we have kept in mind the undoubted fact that a very small proportion of those who study Elementary Geometry, and student it with profit, are destined to become mathematicians in any special sense; and that, to a large majority of students, Euclid is intended to serve not so much as a first lesson in mathematical reasoning, as the first, and sometimes the only, model of formal argument presented in an elementary education."

In the forward to the new edition, it again refers to "elementary teachers." According to http://www.educationengland.org.uk/history/chapter03.html "the Elementary School Code of 1860 had fixed the leaving age for elementary schools at 12." This is in the UK. I don't know if the teaching of the Elements only for upper and upper-middle class students, or if it included a wider range of students.

BTW, here's an advocacy piece for bringing the Elements back as part of the core curriculum - http://www.kysu.edu/NR/rdonlyres/0B03B73A-777B-4571-A554-7DE... .

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by impendia on Monday August 19, 2013 @02:29PM (#6238777)
> a printed sheet of paper, written by someone else would have a bigger impact on the students attending the lecture.

Citation needed.

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @05:56AM (#6242643)
Twenty terrible reasons for lecturing

http://www.brookes.ac.uk/services/ocsld/resources/20reasons....

"The overwhelming outcome of all this work is that there is no significant difference between lecturing and a host of other methods in their ability to enable students to learn factual material. Lectures are as effective as many other methods, but not more so. There are indications that lecturing is less effective, even for imparting information, than certain methods, notably unsupervised reading. (In fact unsupervised reading may have the edge over all face-to-face teaching methods for factual mastery)." (In case this sounds overly positive about lecturing, note that the author considers factual transfer to be lecturing's strongest feature)

It's only a broad review of what was considered fairly obvious research conclusions, he specifically says that he's not writing to present new evidence just to note that despite the evidence no change in behaviour has occurred, and as I say, it was written 30 years ago, but I'm not aware of anything more recent overturning these results.

It's not clear but I believe his source for this particular claim is the Bligh book which is cited explicitly elsewhere in the text, which summarizes hundreds of studies comparing the effectiveness of lecturing with other techniques in his book "What's the use of lectures".

(Amusing aside: The review snippet of Bligh's book on Google books is as follows: "A large portion of this book is dedicated to presenting research on why and how lectures fail. You really have to wade through a lot of material to get to any help in putting a lecture together". I think that neatly encapsulates the mental resistance to abandoning lectures by people who give them)

Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by singingfish on Monday August 19, 2013 @08:16AM (#6236772)
One peer reviewed paper a year. Regardless of quality. Wittgenstein - a philosopher with a major influence on modern life after he died published two short works in a lifetime.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by seanmcdirmid on Monday August 19, 2013 @10:56AM (#6237538)
Don't publish just to publish, only publish what you believe are great papers and don't bother playing the system.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by singingfish on Tuesday August 20, 2013 @06:35AM (#6242777)
So I left academia to become a discordian agent for precisely this reason.
Re:On the Phenomenon of Bullshit Jobs by shin_lao on Monday August 19, 2013 @10:45AM (#6237490)
If someone has no job their perceived lack of purpose ultimately pushes them into mental illness, drug abuses or even suicide.

I agree with this, but I think the real reason is more profound.

I think working is a "need" and then became a social value, not the other way around.

Creating tools and weapons is what gave us an edge as a species, so it wouldn't be that surprising that the need to work is not just a response to social stimuli (although it probably is aswell).