News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I left Google by toyg on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:25PM (#6230743)
Yeah, for somebody so bright and talented (she can't help mentioning her spotless cursus honorum), her writing is incredibly dull.

I expected useful insights in what Google was doing wrong, losing such acclaimed talent, but... nothing. It's all about her wanting to fuck up for once, after a life of unmitigated success. I guess this means Google is actually doing something right by losing her, lest she fucks up the company just because.

Re:Why I left Google by haberman on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:56PM (#6230881)
You're disappointed because you expected the article to be about X, but it was actually about Y, where both X and Y are words in the article's title. (X=Google, Y=I)

Not a great reason to get so unkind.

Re:Why I left Google by toyg on Saturday August 17, 2013 @08:28PM (#6230980)
I probably resent the fact that she leveraged the Google brand in order to make me read lots of words about a perfectly-normal midlife crisis I had no interest in. I clearly put too much trust in the upvoting masses on HN to weed out this sort of stuff.

I apologize if her (or anyone's) feelings were hurt by my comments.

Re:Why I left Google by nostrademons on Sunday August 18, 2013 @12:36AM (#6231666)
There's a certain irony between your comment and her article.

Her article was about how you shouldn't care what other people desire, you should figure out what you desire and go after that. After all, they're not the one living your life.

Your comment is about how you read the article because of the Google brand, and that you trusted the upvoting masses on HN to weed this out. Notice the language. "Google brand" - why does the fact that this has the word "Google" in it make you want to read it? "upvoting masses" - you trust the masses of HN more than your own judgment?

Perhaps there was something in this article that's worth reading after all, and you glossed over it?

(FWIW, it was my upvote that put this article on the front page - it had 2 upvotes on the New page and was 10 minutes old when I saw it, and I liked it, and so gave it the 3rd upvote.)

Re:Why I left Google by toyg on Sunday August 18, 2013 @03:47AM (#6232022)
> you trust the masses of HN more than your own judgment?

I trust the HN hivemind to do (most of) the filtering for me, absolutely. Otherwise I wouldn't read HN, I'd just subscribe to the gazillion feeds out there and read through each and every headline. Despite evidence to the contrary (the number of replies I've written in this thread clearly show that I don't have a highly-driven, high-achieving life similar to TFA's author), I can't dedicate an infinite amount of time to reading stuff on the internet.

Past that, I trust my own judgement in defining what is actually interesting to me by skimming headlines. Finally, once I've read an article, I'm not doubting my inner-self's ability to judge whether the material is actually interesting or not.

This is one of those few times where the two-level filter (HN + me skimming headlines) failed to weed out uninteresting material, and I assign part of the responsibility to the linkbaiting title. I don't think that's unreasonable on my part.

Re:Why I left Google by haberman on Saturday August 17, 2013 @08:43PM (#6231034)
I can see where you're coming from. The people who are upvoting it are probably doing so because they can relate to her struggles and her journey. But for you it's a disappointment because you expected insight about Google and this article does not deliver any.
Re:Why I left Google by null_ptr on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:33PM (#6230783)
We've all read and re-read all the reasons why corporate work can be unfulfilling. In my opinion this short essay wasn't about that, it was about the personal implications of this unfulfillment. Lacking confidence in social interactions, feeling the overburdening need to belong, the realization that it gets harder to steer your life as you age, and the strong will required to turn the wheel.
Re:Why I left Google by benesch on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:29PM (#6230762)
That's a silly argument. She's not looking to maliciously screw something up. She's looking to take a risk—to make a decision that, for once, doesn't lead her down the "safe" path to success of good grades, good college, good internship, good job.
Re:Why I left Google by toyg on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:41PM (#6230812)
From TFA: If I wanted to do nothing, I should. If I wanted to fuck up for once, I should.

Wanted means conscious will: she craves the freedom to do everything she wants, including fucking up. I guess an account manager at Google doesn't get that sort of freedom, which might be a good thing after all.

Re:Why I left Google by meowface on Saturday August 17, 2013 @07:40PM (#6230810)
The writing is pretty dull, but I think that's because of the nature of the situation.

She had a vague dissatisfaction with her time at the company, and she tried to walk people through how she gradually discovered what it was she didn't like.

The whole point of it is that there wasn't any specific thing about Google she didn't really like; that's what makes it interesting (yet also boring and confusing) to read about.