Over the years I noticed a definite improvement in the city. Cars stopped being on fire for one. The Subway, while not exactly the nicest place, isn't bathed in spray paint, etc.
The last few years I started doing week long business trips up there two or three times a year and the city seemed absolutely transformed. Parks were being used by families after dark, streets were generally clean, people were out and about strolling around, biking or exercising. It wasn't Singapore clean, but the streets were generally cleaner, and you really had to get into hard areas to see graffiti. Bars on windows started coming down, and the city felt like it was opening up. I also noticed a huge police presence everywhere.
And people were generally friendlier. Most of that New York snarl was gone (both a positive and a negative).
On one trip I did some consulting work for the NYPD and got a chance to see some of the data the city collects and processes and uses to improve city services -- I believe this system was put in place by Bloomberg. To say it's impressive is an understatement. Noise complaints are correlated to nearby construction and crime, NLP was being brought online to process 911 call transcripts to look for crime trends, recently released prisoners were being cross checked against recent crime reports for recitivism. I think they're still on the edge of what's possible with what they're collecting, but it's being put to immediate and long-term city planning use. It's not quite what you see in the movies, but outside of the federal government, I've never seen anything at quite the scale and level of detail as what NYC collects.
I'll have to say that I do skip the outer boroughs, because they've been particularly unattractive to visitors, but I think in recent years some of the major new development work is starting to make me think again about that. There's lots of downsides to staying in an overpriced cramped hotel room in downtown Manhattan, such as finding a reasonably priced place to eat dinner without heading 20 minutes uptown or eat endless Chinese food. But staying across the river, closer to a residential area with good local eateries might be a better alternative in the future.
If you want to find one group who completely and decisively hates Bloomberg though, just talk to cab drivers. The things that he did regarding new medallions and all of the bullshit with the TLC the last 8 years have made most old-timers quit. The mere mention of the guy's name will bring out some pretty big curse words.
The funny thing is though, most of the crime in the city peaked during the Koch era. He started some of the things that Giuliani and Bloomberg later got credit for. Dinkins gets saddled with a lot of the worst memories of it mostly because of how ineffective he was as Mayor.
Koch did some right dickish things to outerborough New Yorkers though. The closing of bike/pedestrian traffic on the Queensboro Bridge will always stick out in my memory. Caused a 3000+ bike protest down Park Avenue... and a couple years ago they named the fucking bridge after him. >_<
They literally went on strike to protest a pay increase.
Also, when all the new medallions were issued and the GPS/credit system put in their cars, some of the companies passed the cost of install onto the drivers, taking more than the maximum lease rate (The current day rate is like $229, whether you're on the road or not).
Cab drivers aren't making that much money ultimately. It has always been bad but it's way worse now than it used to be (my mom drove a yellow from 1978-1992 before she became an RN).
The overwhelming majority of the money earned in a taxi cab goes to the medallion holders -- owning a medallion is basically a guaranteed 5% ROI because the fare price is fixed. Cab drivers are basically little more than modern sharecroppers. I don't disagree that they're full of shit though, I'm just saying it's a shitty life and a lot of them hate Bloomberg's guts.
Reported revenue increased 14% the following year.
The drivers have come around and admitted the credit card machines increased ridership and revenue drastically. There was a big switch from Black cars to taxis primarily because business travelers can now pay with corporate cards.
Say what? No Village, Chinatown, Little Italy, South Street, Battery, etc., etc.? These are the best parts of Manhattan. No 25 cent trip on the Staten Island Ferry?
Just because they're some of the best parts of Manhattan doesn't mean that they were safe. The East Village certainly wasn't so. All of these areas were pretty damned sketchy and you had some reasonable chance of something bad happening to you. Not a strong likelihood but reasonable enough that you'd only go during the day and be aware of your surroundings.
If you were a gweilo in Chinatown you were pretty much only safe on Canal Street until the late-90s. I've seen with my own eyes people get robbed at gunpoint in the back of Chinatown Fair towards the end of this period and seen gangs beating on each other on Pell Street.
Heck, I saw gangs of kids fighting with chains and baseball bats in the East Village on Rivington as recently as 2007. I've even started seeing junkies back near Tompkins Square Park again. South Street Seaport was still a popular place to find a hooker at night until 9/11.
14th Street, in days past, was a famous dividing line for residents of the city, with many proudly claiming that they either didn't go below it or didn't go above it. I grew up in Midtown, but I still kind of went everywhere. It's only hindsight that gives me the perspective of just how dangerous some of the neighborhoods are, because in my youth I didn't really think about things like I mentioned above.
I grew up in a housing project just East of Chinatown, so I might be calibrated differently. Some people's "dangerous" is my normal.
On the other hand, my time was the '60s and '70s. I left for education in tame New England in '76. This was a high-crime era, but Chinatown and Little Italy were safe if you minded your own business, because organized crime did not tolerate street violence directed at tourists and civilians. This was before the phenomenon of Vietnamese gangs discussed in Fox Butterfield's article. Of course, when I say "Village" I don't mean East Village: Alphabet City was always considered bad.
That neighborhood has a really interesting cyclic history of crime dating all the way back 200 years. The history of Five Points is incredibly interesting to read about.
> Some people's "dangerous" is my normal.
Same here, but I tend to try and refer to things from (what I assume is) the reader's perspective. All of this stuff is pretty normal/safe to me. But I have to be careful and tell myself that it isn't so that I don't get nostalgic for something that was actually terrible.
It's hard for me to settle on a particular viewpoint of the city due to the time and place I grew up...coming from working middle class midtown, getting a private school education with upper-crust kids uptown and having my life and friendships all downtown. There really was sort of a classlessness where I could just fit in anywhere growing up and that feeling has totally disappeared in the last 15-20 years.
> Alphabet City was always considered bad.
Even though I saw Hell's Kitchen/The Deuce and (most of) Harlem transformed, still the strangest thing to me as a New Yorker was watching Alphabet City transform almost overnight. I know that it gentrified quietly over a long period of time but it was always really dangerous until suddenly it wasn't. I would keep going to bars in/around there and it was like a completely different neighborhood inside of three months. A thriving bar/club scene developed out of nothing and then died quickly when everyone moved over to 27th Street for their entertainment and bottle service took over Manhattan. For a short time, Bridge & Tunnels swarmed that place. Now all of the traffic seems to be between Houston & Delancey.
There are some problems though...Bloomberg started the policy of having a bed for every homeless person. Just to keep them off the street and out of the public eye. This is being paid for with taxpayer money and for more than $100/night. A lot of residential buildings on the upper west side have kicked out their tenants to convert exclusively to housing the homeless at high daily rates because of the money. This has contributed to a massive hike in rents across the city. Landlords are definitely the "rich" we're talking about here and Bloomberg has absolutely no problem with the practice.
Giving the homeless singles a place to sleep seems like a good policy not a bad one, and I don't see why the NIMBYites of the upper west side shouldn't bear their share of the burden. Perhaps the city is overpaying, but $100/night is hardly as grotesque as your original $400/night. Finally, in a city with 1.5 million rental apartments, I very much doubt that a few hundred apartments leased by the city for the homeless on the upper west side has contributed to massive hikes in rent across the city.
If you want to blame anything for high market rents blame rent control and rent stabilization. I'd love if Bloomberg had gotten rid of them, but that's one of the third rails of city politics so I don't much hold it against him.
http://www.wnyc.org/articles/wnyc-news/2013/aug/12/homeless-...
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/09/nyregion/for-some-landlord...
In the beginning (or at least the beginning for me, I was pretty young during the Koch era) there was Dinkins, and the city was a crime ridden cesspool. You weren't supposed to take the subway at night, or go anywhere near a park. Parked cars routinely had their radios and sometimes tires stolen. There were very aggressive beggars all over the place. Whole parts of Manhattan, much less the outer boros, were no go zones.
Then came Giuliani. I think most people that lived in the city under Giuliani have very mixed feelings. The crime rate dropped, which was great, but there was very much a sense that a deal had been made with the devil. While to this day stop and frisk is a major issue for minority communities, back then there was a sense that the NYPD was killing and beating up people for no reason. Then there was the whiff of corruption (around Kerik and others), the messy personal life, fights with the unions, and the drama around the Senate race. I'll skip the post-9/11 apotheosis because it's not really relevant in the long run.
So that's when Bloomberg came in. He continued to preside over a drop in crime, but without as much visible divisiveness (though as mentioned above stop and frisk is still very much alive). Ditto with the public sector unions, they were still unhappy but there didn't seem to be the same sense of crises surrounding labor affairs. Meanwhile the finances of the city are very much improved, in spite of looming pension and health care problems the city is in very good financial shape as compared to any other large American city. No one thinks he's corrupt -- people think he's too rich to be corrupt. Then there's the nanny stuff, there's mixed opinions about that, but even smokers seem to be okay with having no smoking in bars. The biggest knock on him is that he only cares about Manhattan and the rich people that live there. That may be true from an emotional standpoint, but from a practical standpoint what he's done has benefited all layers of the city. The gentrification of Manhattan has generated a ton of revenue which is being plowed into services across the city. Honestly other than being better at feeling people's pain, I don't really see the argument.