News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“People simply empty out” by smsm42 on Saturday August 17, 2013 @03:03PM (#6229954)
You can easily leave, but you want to eat. You want to have a place to live, and in a nice neighborhood. You want to be transported to other places. You want to have internet access, to have TV, to have cell phone, to wear nice clothes, etc.

You can not do all of it on your own. Other people have to do it for you. But why other people would do it for you? They don't know you and have no obligations towards you and have no desire to work for you just because you're such a nice person. And even if they wanted, there's a scarcity of resources and time, why would they choose you? You have to offer them something. Like work for them in return, to do something they want but can't or won't do. Of course, you can't work for every person that participated in making your cellphone personally - that's where the money comes in.

Now when you talk about leaving - you can mean giving up all goods that our civilization gives us, sever your links with the mutual work exchange system and do it on your own. You can do that. But do you really want to? Your clothes, food and shelter would suck huge time. A simple caries may kill you. Your life would be brutal, miserable, full of pain and short (at least compared to what the civilization could give you). Is it worth it?

You can also talk about being essentially a parasite - not contributing anything and putting the surrounding people before the choice of giving you stuff for nothing or watching a disturbing picture of you slowly and painfully dying in their front porch. In our modern society, you can pretty safely bet most would choose give you something in order to avoid that. But is that really what anybody would want to be, given a choice?

You can also do worse - you can take weapons and threaten to harm your neighbors unless they work for you. If you demands are modest enough, they may choose to comply instead of creating a security layer that protects against you, since it'd be cheaper. But is it a really moral choice for anyone? If being slave is bad, how about being an enslaver?

If you have another alternative to participating in mutual work exchange system - what is it? How does it compare on outcomes and on morality?

There are no comments on this comment yet.