News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vehicular manslaughter charge upgraded to murder because ... by dragonwriter on Friday August 16, 2013 @10:42PM (#6227984)
> But speeding != intent to commit vehicular manslaughter. "

It is impossible to have intent to commit vehicular manslaughter.

And he isn't being charged with a murder of an intent-to-kill type, he is being charged with murder of the type known as "depraved indifference", or, in the specific language of the California Penal Code, where malice is implied by "an abandoned and malignant heart". (Penal Code Sec. 188)

> Hence, unless you can establish beyond reasonable doubt that his tweets signaled his intent to hurt/maim/kill, it is hard to see how this should be allowed.

First, intent to hurt/maim/kill isn't an element of the crime he is being charged with, so it doesn't need to be proved at all; second, the tweets are not the only evidence being offered of the actual mental state relevant to the crime, so the tweets don't need to prove anything beyond a reasonable doubt by themselves; and third, whether the evidence proves a crime beyond a reasonable doubt is what we have juries for, we don't evaluate whether the evidence proves a crime beyond a reasonable doubt before deciding whether to allow a prosecution to proceed.

There are no comments on this comment yet.