Re:Vehicular manslaughter charge upgraded to murder because ...
by tptacek on Friday August 16, 2013 @09:39PM
(#6227854)
Doing 80 in a 40 and then bragging about it isn't evidence of intent to kill.
It is, however, evidence of a state of mind that comprehends the speed limit and not only disregards it entirely, but does so deliberately.
The law calls that (among other things) "depraved indifference".
Similarly: imagine you got drunk at a friends apartment, picked up a rifle, and fired several rounds through the floor and into the apartment before (this happened with a friend of mine, now deceased). Imagine you killed someone. You clearly didn't intend to, but no reasonable person could fail to grasp the implication of firing a gun blindly into someone else's apartment. You were recklessly indifferent to the lives of the tenants below you, and have committed second-degree murder.
Driving 80 in a 40mph residential zone is no different from firing a gun blindly through the floor of a top-floor apartment. When my late friend did that, I'm sure he had no comprehension that he might have killed someone. Thankfully, he didn't.
It is, however, evidence of a state of mind that comprehends the speed limit and not only disregards it entirely, but does so deliberately.
The law calls that (among other things) "depraved indifference".
Similarly: imagine you got drunk at a friends apartment, picked up a rifle, and fired several rounds through the floor and into the apartment before (this happened with a friend of mine, now deceased). Imagine you killed someone. You clearly didn't intend to, but no reasonable person could fail to grasp the implication of firing a gun blindly into someone else's apartment. You were recklessly indifferent to the lives of the tenants below you, and have committed second-degree murder.
Driving 80 in a 40mph residential zone is no different from firing a gun blindly through the floor of a top-floor apartment. When my late friend did that, I'm sure he had no comprehension that he might have killed someone. Thankfully, he didn't.