News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vehicular manslaughter charge upgraded to murder because ... by tptacek on Friday August 16, 2013 @09:39PM (#6227854)
Doing 80 in a 40 and then bragging about it isn't evidence of intent to kill.

It is, however, evidence of a state of mind that comprehends the speed limit and not only disregards it entirely, but does so deliberately.

The law calls that (among other things) "depraved indifference".

Similarly: imagine you got drunk at a friends apartment, picked up a rifle, and fired several rounds through the floor and into the apartment before (this happened with a friend of mine, now deceased). Imagine you killed someone. You clearly didn't intend to, but no reasonable person could fail to grasp the implication of firing a gun blindly into someone else's apartment. You were recklessly indifferent to the lives of the tenants below you, and have committed second-degree murder.

Driving 80 in a 40mph residential zone is no different from firing a gun blindly through the floor of a top-floor apartment. When my late friend did that, I'm sure he had no comprehension that he might have killed someone. Thankfully, he didn't.

There are no comments on this comment yet.