News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by zcrar70 on Friday May 22, 2009 @08:22AM (#621919)
Welcome to the Real World (Of Large Corporations), Dustin...
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by cubicle67 on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:36AM (#622019)
I think the point is, it doesn't have to be this way. The fact that it is is due largely to those in charge, that have the power to change things, being willing to leave them as is.

[Please read no further if comparisons with Apple annoy you :) ]

This is the public face of AA, and it's crap. No one disputes that, and yet it's still the same. Could you imagine Steve Jobs as CEO of AA seeing this site and taking the excuses given? Can you see him taking "We're fixing it over the next 18 months" as an answer?

[Edit: I think I'll market a new bracelet "WWSJD"]

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by jaxn on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:43AM (#622031)
Yeah, I think 18 months is reasonable.

Here is Apple.com a couple of months after Jobs returned: http://web.archive.org/web/19970404064352/http://www.apple.c...

There was an iterative change about 8 months into Jobs' return. http://web.archive.org/web/19971013114837/http://www4.apple....

Then things really started to get better about month 15: http://web.archive.org/web/19980509035420/http://www.apple.c...

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by bdotdub on Friday May 22, 2009 @10:05AM (#622067)
The thing is is there doesn't seem to be any significant shift at AA. When Jobs came back, there was a changing of culture. With AA, nothing will really force them to change/adapt/make real changes if they can get away with what they're doing now.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by dcurtis on Friday May 22, 2009 @08:54AM (#621967)
You mean the real world of crappy large corporations. Plenty of large companies are not run this badly. At least I hope they're not.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by jaxn on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:36AM (#622020)
I am really impressed by AA's response.

What is the largest team you have worked on?

I read the letter and your reply. I love the Ira Glass series on taste as well, but do you really want your business analyst to have great taste? I mean, it might not hurt, but I can't imagine making that a job requirement.

AA is not in business to make pretty websites. They are in business to effectively get people from point A to point B. Their website is effective. Your mockup is not as effective for some of the ways I interact with AA.com.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by dcurtis on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:52AM (#622039)
An interface is just a transporter to help you get from where you are to a place where your goal is completed. That's it. There are varying levels of "effectiveness" in transporting you, though, and that's where the quality of the interface comes in.

For example, AA's current website is "effective" in the same way it is effective to travel 50 miles from here by walking. But what if you gave me a bike? What about a car?

AA is in the business of giving their customers an enjoyable experience. They just happen to transport them via airplane as their business. Or at least that's how a customer experience designer should look at it, I think.

And stuff like this is just totally unacceptable: http://dustincurtis.com/screenshots/Photoshop-20090522-08344... .

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by jaxn on Friday May 22, 2009 @10:06AM (#622068)
You are wrong.

On the front page of AA.com I can log into my frequent flyer account without having to click to go to a login form.

Being able to select a date with the calendar is much more effective when trying to make plans three months out. Parsing unstructured data from text fields is "cool" but increases ambiguity for the majority of users.

What if I want to buy a ticket with points or want to only see flights that have first class available? You're design is going to require me to fill out two forms (or toggle filters at some point).

The AA.com website is not perfect. However, it is effective in ways your mockup is not.

Your position is extremely arrogant and I doubt that you have the experience to back it up.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by dcurtis on Friday May 22, 2009 @10:15AM (#622079)
My mockup isn't perfect, and it wasn't intended to be. Your questions and requirements are all valid. Considering the current site acceptable is what bothers me.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by myoung8 on Friday May 22, 2009 @01:39PM (#622414)
I agree that AA.com is a terrible experience, but consider the decision to redesign the site from a business perspective: will making it an order of magnitude more usable increase AA's bottom line by more than some other project they are considering (e.g. opening a new destination)?

I don't know the answer to that, but AA is run by business people so I would wager that the answer is "no," otherwise they would be doing it already.

I think there are some intangible benefits to having a more usable website, but those are intrinsically difficult/impossible to measure so they don't factor into the business decisions.

As a designer, I feel your pain, but the unfortunate reality of the situation is that AA is driven by their bottom line and a more usable website probably won't net them the greatest ROI right now.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by pg on Friday May 22, 2009 @01:40PM (#622416)
GM is run by business people.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by ryanwaggoner on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:44PM (#623031)
I don't think he's arguing that business people don't make mistakes, just that they take a more holistic view of the various options to improve the bottom line, rather than just looking at one extremely narrow slice of a multi-billion-dollar multi-national company.

I would rather have "business people" running GM than someone who thinks that redesigning the GM website will solve all their woes...or any of their woes.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by pg on Saturday May 23, 2009 @12:02AM (#623124)
In GM's case the corresponding thing would not be to redesign their site but to redesign their dealer network, which would actually be a really good idea.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by jaxn on Saturday May 23, 2009 @02:01AM (#623195)
Which brings up an important piece of information that we are missing.

What percentage of AA's bookings come from their website, and what percentages come from travel sites like expedia or from travel agents. I know a large number of AA's customers are business travelers.

If 10% of bookings come from the website and they are able to increase it's effectiveness 50%, that would only result in a 5% increase in sales.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by Xichekolas on Friday May 22, 2009 @10:48AM (#622126)
> AA is in the business of giving their customers an enjoyable experience. They just happen to transport them via airplane as their business. Or at least that's how a customer experience designer should look at it, I think.

Close, but I think the problem comes from the top. Only management has the power to crush corporate turf wars, which are almost certainly the cause of teams that don't really work together. The only way this would honestly change is if you had a push from the top, and I'm willing to bet the senior management at AA never uses the website. (Why would they?) To them, it's just another division of sales.

If the CEO had to book all his flights himself on the website, you can bet there would be some improvements, because he would force people to fix things. Without that weight from above, teams can get away with not working together. Witness Apple's website. Their senior management (notably that one guy), definitely cares about the look and feel of _every_ aspect of the business, including the website, which I'm sure he looks at personally from time to time.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by raganwald on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:25PM (#622480)
When I worked with that 1.8 trillion dollar company, the CTO of the USA group would blackberry me with suggestions after trying our test sites. He definitely used it and would show it to the CEO, then pass feedback directly to the team.

I can't imagine what would have happend if I'd replied Sorry, no can do your suggestion because group A and group B both need to be appeased as part of this project.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by amalcon on Friday May 22, 2009 @01:03PM (#622346)
If AA is not in the business of making pretty websites (websites at all, in fact), wouldn't it be more sensible to contract the website out to someone who is in that business? They'll probably be better at it.

I mean, most online retailers contract out their shipping.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by rgrieselhuber on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:02AM (#621974)
Out of curiosity, what is your experience in producing web content for a site that serves dozens if not hundreds of business requirements at any given time?

EDIT: at the scale of a site like AA.com or any global company?

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by dcurtis on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:43AM (#622030)
I've only done very brief advising to groups in big companies, a long time ago. I've never worked in one. I can't imagine the horror.

But it doesn't really matter if the company is big or small, does it? The end result still has to be of some level of quality regardless of the requirements. If something is wrong, there's either a problem on the business side (too many requirements/unfocused goals) or on the design side (bad designers).

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by rgrieselhuber on Friday May 22, 2009 @10:04AM (#622063)
The reason I ask is not because I disagree with your demands for higher quality. What I think you're missing is just how difficult it is to organize that many people and interests.

If you want your suggestions to be taken seriously, you need to provide them in a way that addresses those problems instead of simply demanding better results.*

* I'm assuming you were writing primarily as a design critic, not as a frustrated consumer -- although I understand that the latter motivated the former.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by raganwald on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:27PM (#622485)
What I think you're missing is just how difficult it is to organize that many people and interests.

With respect for your suggestion and with passion for my opinion, it isn't Dustin's job to organize that many people and interests, it's management's job. If they run a company that functions like warring city-states, there's little anybody else can do. If they have united all the teams to work together on a single goal, that's a different story.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by rgrieselhuber on Friday May 22, 2009 @08:10PM (#622934)
I don't disagree with that either, but this is something I've been thinking about a lot recently.

Perhaps it is impossible to change the structure of these organizations, but I think there is going to be fundamental disconnect between designers and the organizations they serve until one group at least learns to speak the other's language and address the problems they face.

At the very minimum, it sounds like there is an opportunity to weed out inefficiency (somehow) and find newer, better ways to organize people and their interests.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by sofal on Friday May 22, 2009 @11:32AM (#622189)
I disagree with your demands for higher quality.

Why? Because it's too hard? Does the difficulty of organizing that many people and interests cancel out the need for a better user experience? Is the market going to forgive AA because it knows that it's just really hard to get things done at AA?

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by dandelany on Friday May 22, 2009 @08:05PM (#622931)
Re-read that:

"The reason I ask is not because I disagree with your demands for higher quality." (emphasis mine)

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by sofal on Saturday May 23, 2009 @09:45AM (#623434)
Woops.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by joshwa on Friday May 22, 2009 @06:26PM (#622828)
Nope, the market is going to forgive AA because it didn't spend money on a new site and passed that $2.50 in savings per ticket on to the customer, which puts them $2.50 cheaper than the other guys, which nets them far more incremental sales than a better site would (at least so the theory goes).
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by edw519 on Friday May 22, 2009 @09:58AM (#622052)
"I can't imagine the horror."

lol

Try to look at it from another perspective. Getting lots of quality work done quickly? Yes, horror. But there are lots of things you encounter in these large organizations you simply don't see elsewhere. In terms of requirements, logistical issues, volumes, people, politics, etc. Once you push the envelope of your personal experience by dealing with these things, you become much better at everything, including lots of stuff you do for small companies.

Think of it as practicing basketball with a smaller hoop. I have always oscillated between large and small companies, trying to assimilate the best of both. The battle scars from the horror will probably come in handy later.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by raganwald on Friday May 22, 2009 @10:03AM (#622061)
I don't know about "plenty," but I worked for a company with 1.8 trillion dollars in assets. They have a simple, very accessible self-service web site for their customers, and they work very hard on breaking down the factional fighting and silos that prevent a talented UX architect from actually doing his(?) job.

Of course, they have it much easier in that they have a fanatical obsession with simplifying their product and service line rather than complificating it beyond human understanding.

I'm thinking it is not a coïncidence that a company with a usuable self-service web site happens to be a company with simple, easy-to-understand products and pricing.

Hard for me to say anything about AA's management, I am no expert. But looking at their web site, I would rather own the other company's stock.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by Xichekolas on Friday May 22, 2009 @10:44AM (#622120)
Just curious, can you reveal which company you are talking about? ING comes to mind, but mostly because I'm a happy customer and I figure a company with $1.8 trillion in assets has to be a bank.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by raganwald on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:29PM (#622491)
Or an insurance company! But I don't discuss my former clients and/or employers in public. But since you mention ING Direct, despite being much larger than most of the US banks that are their competition, they somehow act like the nimble underdogs.
Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by hpvic03 on Friday May 22, 2009 @02:37PM (#622505)
I heard Herb Kelleher talk last year. He said:

No matter what business you're in, you're in the business of customer service

I think that having a well designed website would go under that category. And whether Dustin's design is great or not is irrelevant; the fact is that their current website can be vastly improved.

Re:Response to Dustin Curtis from AA UX person by jamiequint on Friday May 22, 2009 @12:14PM (#622269)
Steve Blank said in one of his Customer Development class podcasts on Venture Hacks that the natural way companies scale is replacing creativity with automation. Its very hard to have a large scale organization work when lots of people have autonomy and the freedom to be creative.