News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by bluedino on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:02AM (#6218201)
>> That’s $324,000 a year. But for just $120,000, the company could buy all the physical servers it needed for the job

What about power, cooling, rent in the building for the room you're keeping them in, backup generator, internet connectivity, administration costs (setup, repairs, installation), etc?

>> “The public cloud is phenomenal if you really need its elasticity,” Frenkiel says. “But if you don’t — if you do a consistent amount of workload — it’s far, far better to go in-house.”

Yup.

Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by hhw on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:18PM (#6218827)
$120,000 worth of servers is maybe 2-3 cabinets. $1100/mo /w 40A @120V each in most major markets, so let's just say $3,300/mo. Add in a 1Gb commit on a 10Gb link of quality bandwidth for another $2,000/mo, and all-in-all you're looking at $5,300/mo or $63,600/yr in operating expenses. Considering the hardware will probably last you 3 years, the hardware cost is actually only $40,000/yr, for a total of $103,600 vs $324,000. You'd easily be cutting your costs by 2/3rds.
Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by csears on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:20AM (#6218330)
There's also the an opportunity cost to consider if your actual demand turns out to be higher than projected and you're not able to scale up to meet it.

I think we'll see more companies using a hybrid model where you can run your steady-state workload level on dedicated gear but with the ability burst into a cloud to handle peaks and flash demand.

Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by Gravityloss on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:01PM (#6218656)
You can have considerable reserve capability and it's still cheaper than the cloud.

Also renting dedicated servers can be really fast.

Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by nasalgoat on Friday August 16, 2013 @01:47PM (#6225567)
My experience with cloud overflow configurations is that it never works as nicely as you expect, due to a lot of the drawbacks of cloud infrastructure such as variable performance and latency issues.
Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by mjolk on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:50AM (#6218543)
>What about power, cooling, rent in the building for the room >you're keeping them in, backup generator, internet >connectivity,

Most companies that I've dealt with just rent space in a colo and those costs, plus bandwidth, are far less than $200k.

>administration costs (setup, repairs, >installation), etc?

It doesn't take that long to rack and stack. Maybe a day for 20 servers if you're doing it alone.

Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by snowwolf on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:58AM (#6218616)
And how many extra 'DevOps' people has the company now had to employ to manage these physical servers, and what is their annual salary? This never seems to be factored into the calculations.
Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by beat on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:06PM (#6218706)
That was my first thought, too. Physical hardware == more staff. Also consider the risk management of keeping your security up to date, and the opportunity costs of making it easy to use for developers. Spend some time in old-school enterprise, and you'll see just how much pain and grief can happen.

Remember, Amazon built its cloud not for the public, but for itself! The cloud gave them a clean separation of duties and cost management between application development and operations. That sort of thing can save large amounts of money and bureaucratic headache. They started selling AWS to the public only after they had a stable system that could produce excess capacity, which could then be resold.

Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by simonebrunozzi on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:51PM (#6219097)
The "excess capacity" is a pure myth. When AWS started, it was using a set of Data Centers which had nothing to do with Amazon.com (the Retail part of it). Now Amazon.com is just another (big) customer of AWS.

Disclaimer: I work for AWS.

Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by purple_horse on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:20PM (#6218833)
With modern tools like Fully Automatic Install and Ansible/Puppet it shouldn't be any more than for a Cloud service.
Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by beat on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:30PM (#6218928)
But once you have a legacy system, getting the modern tools in there can be a real pain.

Instant snowflake, just add expensive and archaic enterprise middleware.

Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by purple_horse on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:57PM (#6219144)
True, but the article is talking about a startup building from scratch.
Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by thezilch on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:47PM (#6219072)
One? Your colo probably also will rent you help to rack, wire, and anything else physical. How many days do you expect to be "downtown?" Apart from the physical / racking aspect, it's not like your Ops has any less work to do with respect to clouds. You still have to manage your own software services, security, etc on either platform.

You could triple your provisions with the savings of not being on the cloud, so it's hard to believe you won't see the train coming, if the concern is having to rack more than 20-60 servers a day. Arguably, that would be a good problem to have!

Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by echohack on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:22PM (#6218857)
This this this. And what is the turnaround time on getting new servers provisioned for development? Are they using Docker, or are they stuck in Windows land where there's no open source private PaaS solution that makes any sense? How many of those servers have virtual machines provisioned and then those virtual machines sit idle? How long until the cruft virtual machines are so populous that they take up an ever increasing amount of your internal infrastucture and it's a nightmare to manage?
Re:Why Some Startups Say the Cloud Is a Waste of Money by waxzce on Thursday August 15, 2013 @12:42PM (#6219035)
You can also use public PaaS