Re:Campaign for a new HTTP Error code: 451 - Blocked for leg...
by nawitus on Thursday August 15, 2013 @07:30AM
(#6217163)
Technically speaking 403 can be returned if it's blocked for legal reasons, but obviously it would be nice to know why it is forbidden.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Campaign for a new HTTP Error code: 451 - Blocked for leg...
by txutxu on Thursday August 15, 2013 @07:53AM
(#6217240)
There is some reasoning about this on: http://www.451unavailable.org/why-do-we-need-error-451
Still, imho, 4XX could be a response for a given URL, but when "a website is blocked" (from the text of the previous URL), we should go to 5XX, as in 503 - service unavailable.
Re:Campaign for a new HTTP Error code: 451 - Blocked for leg...
by eli on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:11AM
(#6217299)
5xx does not really make sense for a single page removed due to DMCA.
Re:Campaign for a new HTTP Error code: 451 - Blocked for leg...
by txutxu on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:23AM
(#6217338)
Yes, I don't know if two codes (one for URL and one for the entire site) could make sense in this case.
Re:Campaign for a new HTTP Error code: 451 - Blocked for leg...
by orenbarzilai on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:12AM
(#6217302)
does it really matter if it's 5xx or 4xx?
Re:Campaign for a new HTTP Error code: 451 - Blocked for leg...
by zackkitzmiller on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:26AM
(#6217347)
Yes. 400 responses are because of client error. 500 responses are for server error.
Re:Campaign for a new HTTP Error code: 451 - Blocked for leg...
by jvdh on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:28AM
(#6217358)
Legal restrictions on content are almost always issues on the client side, otherwise they should not be made available at all.
Consider for example the blocking of sites in the UK, or the blocking of the PirateBay website in the Netherlands. Those are all very limited audiences where the location of the client is causing a legal reason why the content can not be displayed.