News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nutraloaf by DanBC on Thursday August 15, 2013 @07:27AM (#6217152)
There are many single sources of nutrition that are cheaper than Soylent.

Have a look at the WFP information here (https://www.wfp.org/nutrition/special-nutritional-products) and here (http://documents.wfp.org/stellent/groups/public/documents/co...)

And the manufacturer page for some of these products here (http://www.dsm.com/corporate/home.html)

This report from IRIN shows the extreme need to lower costs with these foods - they're aiming at $4 per kg. (http://www.irinnews.org/report/83124/malawi-cheaper-recipe-f...)

Re:Nutraloaf by freejack on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:48AM (#6217421)
With apologies to the original...

"You tell everybody. Listen to me. Hatcher. You've gotta tell 'em! SOYLENT IS MARKETING SPIN! We gotta stop them! Somehow! Listen! Listen to me… PLEASE!!!"

I'm not judging and I wish the creators well - there's just not a lot of real new thinking in Soylent - most of its promise is just pure marketing, like most products I suppose ;-)

Re:Nutraloaf by DanBC on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:56AM (#6217463)
It is remarkably effective marketing. We've been able to walk into any drugstore and buy equivalent products for many years, so for Soylent to generate the buzz they have is amazing.

It's certainly a good thing to put on their resume.

Re:Nutraloaf by kirualex on Thursday August 15, 2013 @09:03AM (#6217491)
Soylent success was not due to a Marketing campaign, but to one blog article that buzzed at the time (when Soylent was not even considered being marketed) : http://robrhinehart.com/?p=298 The Soylent compaign was launch purely because of its success, not the other way around.
Re:Nutraloaf by kirualex on Thursday August 15, 2013 @09:11AM (#6217521)
There are two types of foods I find depicted in those documents : - "Emergency" foods used to prevent malnutrition - Supplements in order to balance an unhealthy diet and/or reach individual needs

It seems that these goals are completely different from the one of Soylent, which is to provide a food replacement altogether (meaning people will expect it to taste good, make them feel replenished and won't use it as part of a treatment).

Re:Nutraloaf by jacques_chester on Thursday August 15, 2013 @09:12AM (#6217526)
Then buy a commercial MRP. There are cheap ones around.
Re:Nutraloaf by masukomi on Thursday August 15, 2013 @09:33AM (#6217629)
It is my impression that Meal Replacement Plans aren't generally designed to be lived off of exclusively, but as intermittent substitutes to normal meals, or temporary replacements for them. That is a very different goal than what Soylent is trying to accomplish.
Re:Nutraloaf by DanBC on Thursday August 15, 2013 @09:45AM (#6217692)
There are plenty of meal replacement products that can be used as a sole source of nutrition.

The manufacturers don't heavily promote that aspect because they are cautious and careful.

Re:Nutraloaf by batemanesque on Friday August 16, 2013 @06:41PM (#6227138)
given that we don't yet know the full range of nutrients the human body needs to function, it'll be completely impossible to live off Soylent & stay healthy in the long term. it's really that simple.
Re:Nutraloaf by kirualex on Thursday August 15, 2013 @09:36AM (#6217644)
Most of the MRP I found are ultra-high on protein and overall aimed toward muscle development. A comparison with Soylent (once its out) could be very interesting though.
Re:Nutraloaf by jacques_chester on Thursday August 15, 2013 @10:22AM (#6217902)
If you're eating at a deficit, high protein is good idea, actually. It helps preserve lean mass, which has important downstream health effects.
Re:Nutraloaf by kirualex on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:29AM (#6218388)
I'm not eating about any deficit eating, but normal eating. And high protein is not always a good idea. Everybody doesnt have the same needs. Also there can be long term effect, some of which are still being studied. http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/high-protein-diets/AN00847
Re:Nutraloaf by DanBC on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:50AM (#6218545)
There are a wide variety of meal replacement products. Some have high protein, others don't. Some have high calories, some have even higher calories, some don't.

There is plenty of variety in the meal replacement product marketplace.

Here are the brands made by one company (http://abbottnutrition.com/brands/abbott-brands) - they cover just about anything you'd need.

Re:Nutraloaf by asdasf on Thursday August 15, 2013 @09:58AM (#6217759)
Why does everyone insist on recommending people consume completely inappropriate "alternatives" to soylent that will cause health problems with 100% certainty?
Re:Nutraloaf by DanBC on Thursday August 15, 2013 @10:11AM (#6217837)
Wait, what?

Commercial providers have been making and supplying these foods for many years, and they've been used in a variety of settings for a long time.

How are these worse than Soylent, a product created by people who don't know what they're doing in their kitchens and advertised with a variety of probably illegal claims used with no medical supervision?

Re:Nutraloaf by asdasf on Thursday August 15, 2013 @10:23AM (#6217910)
They have been making and supplying them for many years, but they are not designed as a replacement for food, and do not contain 100% of known essential nutrients. Recommending something that we absolutely know for certain is not complete because you have an irrational hate-boner for soylent is absurd. Your claims about soylent are false by the way, which really doesn't help your case at all.
Re:Nutraloaf by DanBC on Thursday August 15, 2013 @10:28AM (#6217949)
> but they are not designed as a replacement for food, and do not contain 100% of known essential nutrients.

This is wrong. I'm not sure what products you're talking about. But there are products that are designed to be used as a sole source of nutrition.

> Recommending something that we absolutely know for certain is not complete because you have an irrational hate-boner for soylent is absurd.

> Your claims about soylent are false by the way, which really doesn't help your case at all.

Feel free to rebut anything I've said with links.

Soylent have no dieticians on staff, or anyone with any nutrition qualifications. So far all product has been produced in their kitchen. Several mistakes in formulation have been made. Errors in mixing (not taking fineness of powers into account, for example) have been shown.

Re:Nutraloaf by asdasf on Thursday August 15, 2013 @10:55AM (#6218140)
>I'm not sure what products you're talking about

The ones referenced in the post I replied to.

>Soylent have no dieticians on staff

Yes they do.

>So far all product has been produced in their kitchen

No, it hasn't.

>Several mistakes in formulation have been made

And you seem to be under the misconception that it is still some guy tossing stuff together in his kitchen. That is not the case.

Re:Nutraloaf by DanBC on Thursday August 15, 2013 @11:23AM (#6218355)
> The ones referenced in the post I replied to.

The FBFs are complete foods. The others are supplements designed to help in cases of extreme malnutrition, or in cases of mild malnutrition.

>> Soylent have no dieticians on staff > > Yes they do.

(https://campaign.soylent.me/soylent-free-your-body)

Rob Rhinehart - CEO

Matt Cauble - COO

John Coogan - CTO

David Renteln - VP Business Development/Sales

Julio Miles - VP Customer Success

You'd have thought they'd list the dieticians.

I get no results when I search the Soylent blog. (http://blog.soylent.me/search/dietitian)(http://blog.soylent...

Please, help me out. Who are the dietitians on the Soylent staff?

Re:Nutraloaf by asdasf on Thursday August 15, 2013 @02:50PM (#6219825)
Why do you think they would list every single employee and contractor in their funding campaign? Why do you think I know their names? They say those people exist, there is no reason to believe otherwise, you contradict them with no evidence.

http://www.vice.com/en_uk/read/rob-rhinehart-interview-soyle...

Re:Nutraloaf by DanBC on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:14PM (#6221437)
> Why do you think they would list every single employee

When you're selling a food replacement the dietitian isn't a minor role. It's a key role in the company. Combine that with the criticism that Soylent has received from registered dietitians and it's important to list some dietitian, if only to counter the negative results when I type [soylent dietitian] into a search engine.

Reading the article you point me to I see ...

> Once we got some professional dietitians and food scientists to collaborate with us it got much tastier and more filling

... which is a little bit different from your claim that dietitians are on staff. Maybe that's for the future, with Soylent v2 or v3, when they move to more individualisation?

EDIT: Note that this is a blatant lie:

> A lot of things will give you calories, but nothing so far has been designed to be something you can live off. There are no food replacements on the market.

There are plenty of food replacement products, products that are designed for people to live off, in the market. It's not easy to get hold of them because other sellers have some sense of responsibility to their customers.

> FDA-approved,

Another lie!

Re:Nutraloaf by asdasf on Friday August 16, 2013 @09:30AM (#6223853)
You do understand that just saying "that's a lie" over and over doesn't do anything right? You have absolutely no credibility, you have no evidence to support your claims, and you have an obvious emotional investment in trashing the project. If you want to convince other people to hate soylent with you, start using evidence.
Re:Nutraloaf by jacques_chester on Thursday August 15, 2013 @07:42PM (#6221319)
So there are no dietitians listed anywhere, in any form, but you feel there must be a secret dietitian somewhere because the Soylent boys are such swells?