Re:Is there any such thing as 'road tax'? (UK: Cars vs Cycli...
by slgeorge on Thursday August 15, 2013 @08:14AM
(#6217311)
I don't accept the argument, but as a thought experiment lets go with it. So motorists pay for the roads and for trains - so what?
I pay lots of tax for services I don't use - or perhaps someone else doesn't pay for something I also use (public libraries for example) - but so what? We pay tax and we may use some, all or none of the services provided - it's just part of the bargain with the state to create a civil society.
Just because you've paid tax (greater or lesser) doesn't give you more or less access to services as a citizen.
Re:Is there any such thing as 'road tax'? (UK: Cars vs Cycli...
by tehwalrus on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:33AM
(#6217025)
Almost all roads are maintained by council tax, which is genuinely separate from Vehicle Excise Duty which goes to the treasury. The highways agency roads (mostly A roads and motorways) are usually not safe for/used by cyclists anyway.
Re:Is there any such thing as 'road tax'? (UK: Cars vs Cycli...
by skrause on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:00AM
(#6216951)
http://tu-dresden.de/die_tu_dresden/fakultaeten/vkw/ivs/oeko... suggests that the total cost of cars in the UK are around £50B per year.
Your argument also suggest that all cyclists don't pay taxes at all.
Re:Is there any such thing as 'road tax'? (UK: Cars vs Cycli...
by blibble on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:08AM
(#6216966)
that document assigns a future expected value of £30B for damages due to climate change caused by cars... which to be frank, is a bullshit made up number.
take that out, and motorists still make a profit for the treasury.
my argument is purely based on receipts from purchase of fuel... if there were 0 motor vehicles on the road, the receipts would be many orders of magnitude lower.
in 2013 the the treasury expects to collect £26B[1] via fuel duty alone (the tax motorists pay on petrol/diesel), and the entire transport budget is £21B[2], so it's accurate to say that the motorist's taxes pay entirely for the roads (and a good chunk of the trains too).
(note the £26B fuel duty figure doesn't include the 20% VAT motorists also pay on petrol, and the money from VED)
[1]: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm... page 103
[2]: same document, page 10