Re:Grasshopper 100m Lateral Divert Test
by btilly on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:53PM
(#6212633)
To understand this project you have to remember that Elon Musk's goal is Mars colonization.
The goal is a rapidly reusable launch system that can be deployed anywhere in the solar system. A parachute system would work well here on Earth, but the martian air is too thin for it to work there. Therefore they are aiming to make it work straight off of rockets.
As for the fuel issue, if I remember Elon's figures right, SpaceX currently takes a $100 million rocket, fills it with $100k of fuel, launches it, and throws away the rocket. Hence the desire to reuse the rocket.
He's far from the first to try this. But the potential failure mode that others encountered is along the lines of what you indicate. You wind up with a reusable rocket that gets to altitude and back, but which is unable to lift a useful payload on top of that. He thinks that he can avoid this, but has not proven it yet. However even if he needs 10x as much fuel per pound lifted into orbit, he's still saving money. (His actual goal is, I think, 10% of his current launch cost.)
The goal is a rapidly reusable launch system that can be deployed anywhere in the solar system. A parachute system would work well here on Earth, but the martian air is too thin for it to work there. Therefore they are aiming to make it work straight off of rockets.
As for the fuel issue, if I remember Elon's figures right, SpaceX currently takes a $100 million rocket, fills it with $100k of fuel, launches it, and throws away the rocket. Hence the desire to reuse the rocket.
He's far from the first to try this. But the potential failure mode that others encountered is along the lines of what you indicate. You wind up with a reusable rocket that gets to altitude and back, but which is unable to lift a useful payload on top of that. He thinks that he can avoid this, but has not proven it yet. However even if he needs 10x as much fuel per pound lifted into orbit, he's still saving money. (His actual goal is, I think, 10% of his current launch cost.)