News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by parennoob on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:31AM (#6211693)
It's surprising how immigration is almost never mentioned as an alternative to these "population-drop-fighting" measures. You'd think one of the things they'd do was make it easier for immigrants with some level of skill to get permanent residency.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by rayiner on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:01AM (#6211899)
Immigration isn't a panacea. You have to be able to absorb and acculturate those immigrants, and you have a finite capacity to do that.

This will yield down votes, but I'm an immigrant from the subcontinent and I understand what I'm talking about when I say this: it is vital to preserve western culture. Immigration done right can strengthen it and keep it vital, but done wrong it can dilute and corrupt the culture.

Germany is better than India or China or the Middle East or the other countries immigrants would come from. Full stop. Westerners don't appreciate the extent to which a lot of the bad things we perceive to characterize those countries is baked into their culture. Sexism, racism, corruption at the basest level. That will follow immigrants into Germany and take root there unless immigration is slow enough to acculturate the immigrants.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by dctoedt on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:38PM (#6212521)
> it is vital to preserve western culture. Immigration done right can strengthen it and keep it vital, but done wrong it can dilute and corrupt the culture.

I've read that the pressure of xenophobia was a big contributor to the assimilation of past waves of American immigrants. Three of my four grandparents were working-class immigrants or the offspring thereof. There was never any doubt they wanted to be, and indeed became or grew up as, "real Americans" --- in no small part because they were (at a minimum) looked down on by the "real Americans."

Certainly xenophobia is not especially admirable. But these days there's a danger of going too far in the other direction: There seems to be a species of political correctness that insists (sometimes loudly) that every other culture is at least as virtuous as American/Western culture and should be allowed to take root and spread in whatever fertile Western environment its human carriers decide they want to live in.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by brazzy on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:10AM (#6211967)
It goes both ways: there seems to be a percentage somewhere between 5% and 10% of "strangers" that people can accept living among them without feeling threatened. If that percentage is exceeded and the main population starts to feel threatened, you get xenophobia and things turn ugly.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kamakazizuru on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:35PM (#6212500)
That has to be the most ridiculous statement - especially since you claim to come from the subcontinent yourself. Every country has its share of problems and cultural differences - but you're looking at it from a very pessimistic and negative perspective. Germany and any other country can put in measures to ensure the kind of people do immigrate are also ones that would fit into their societies. They don't need to haul them over in boatfulls.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by rayiner on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:04PM (#6212732)
For immigration to serve as a counterweight to declining birth rates, you do need to haul people over in boatfulls. And its a modern classist conceit that the virtues of western culture come from education and wealth rather than socialization and upbringing. There are plenty of educated wealthy middle easterners who cover their daughters faces in public and believe its morally acceptable.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kamakazizuru on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:14PM (#6215082)
Actually - in a number of those countries its legally required for them to be covered. The point is different - you can't use an extreme example of a hijab to claim that western values are uniquely good - and those coming from eastern countries only create a negative cultural impact. If you understood the point of the article - the goal isn't to increase the birth rate. The goal is to make sure the population doesn't fall to a level where it will not be able to sustain the social structures that exist. This can be countered by controlled highly skilled immigration and is working perfectly fine in Canada and New Zealand among other places. For what its worth though - of all people you should probably be glad not everyone thought that people from the east should stay where they are - otherwise you with all your extreme views on this would've still been stuck in your walled garden in India. Driving around in your foreign car. What an unfortunate existence!
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by philipp-de on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:54AM (#6211851)
Immigration is unpopular here in germany. Indeed, it is very unpopular among many people.

German politicians, in the past (60s,70s,80s), have brought in many worker-immigrants mainly from turkey. They were badly needed to fill the many vacant spots in the booming economy.

They left no thought to integrating / assimilating them into the german society. Up until the 1990s the political parties in germany could not even come to grips with the fact that germany was in fact an "immmigration country". They were in denial.

Today germany has 12-14% foreigners, mostly from turkey, and many of them have not been integrated well into the german society. Also, unemployment is high among this group. Education chances are depressed, etc - you get the picture.

Now, we are in a bind. On the one hand the birth rate has been dropping for decades. This has to do with societal trends (more women working, etc) - but is a complicated issue in itself.

Only group with a healthy birth rate, ironically, are the turkish immigrants.

Politicians do not have any idea what to do about the birthrate. That has to with a cultural memory of nazi-era family policies, which rewarded having many children. It's a taboo today in german politics to try to directly induce families to have more children in any way.

The german economy is already suffering. The term "fachkräftemangel" has been coined for this- which means the industry is already finding it difficult to fill all the vacant spots with qualified personell.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kayoone on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:01AM (#6211903)
Correct, in fact in general families/women from lower income and education levels (no matter if immigrants or not) tend to have more children than higher educated couples that prioritize their career. Overall germany is also not a very family-with-children-friendly country. This is in stark contrast to, for example, the US.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by rbehrends on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:23PM (#6212413)
While Germany has plenty of room for improvement, I'd hardly call the US a shining example of a country that's great for families with children, either.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kayoone on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:51PM (#6212620)
But the overall mentality towards Families with children is alot different from my experience.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by rbehrends on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:50PM (#6213068)
Not in my experience, and families with children face a great many obstacles.

The abortion rate in the US is about three times that of Germany; the majority of women who have an abortion cite that they cannot afford to have a child as a primary reason.

There is no statutory maternity leave in the US (let alone parental leave).

Depending on what health insurance you have, even having a baby can be pretty pricey; a friend of mine who recently had a baby ended up paying over $2,500 in coinsurance for the delivery alone.

Daycare is generally much more expensive than in Germany, where daycare is heavily subsidized (daycare subsidies for low-income families vary by state).

Having a positive attitude towards families with children is great (and it's arguable whether there's actually a difference), but it doesn't put food on a table or a roof over their head.

The biggest practical problem that German parents face, in my experience, is that schools or daycare centers that are out at noon are difficult to square away with having both a job and children (though the problem of latchkey kids is hardly unknown in the US, either; google "Kim Brathwaite", for example).

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by waps on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:12PM (#6213921)
Whatever the reason, the US is doing something right.

US fertility : 2.06 German fertility : 1.42 (this is WITH 10%-15% turkish immigrants having a birthrate of > 2.4)

So what is it ?

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @05:30PM (#6214420)
Hispanics have high birth rates, and they are a growing minority (30%?), a majority in many states. Also, we have subgroups like Mormons who are very old school catholic in having lots of kids.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kamakazizuru on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:47PM (#6212585)
I think you hit the nail on the head here. Germany it seems will continue to pay for this mistake from the 50/60/70s in a number of ways unfortunately.

People are now afraid of immigrants in general. Most people don't realize that there is a VERY big difference to the economy from an Indian IT worker - who learns German - assimilates himself culturally (maybe even studied a masters or something in Germany - picking up the finer bits of your complicated culture) & the Turkish family in the shady part of the city thats living on Hartz 4. This is a huge issue for a country thats trying hard to attract foreigners (www.make-it-in-germany.com).

Most other immigrants I know here - eventually get tired of this feeling of constantly have to justify that they arent here to mooch of the system - and are probably providing for some family in Brandenburg with their monthly tax and social security payments (most educated immigrants earn atleast 40-50k€ - its a natural lower limit set by the fact that you cant get a permit otherwise). This means easily 15-20k € in tax and Social security (and lovely SOLI of course) - with which they are supporting a society that looks at them as leeches.

Dont get me wrong - Germans are tolerant - but that's different from inclusive. The tendency is to assume "oh these poor 3rd world people need to come here to have a good living." That simply isnt true - a well qualified person can live an equally good life in the developing world as he would in Germany. (sure maybe not everything is always on time but so what). Many people move to Germany for other reasons - be it hte love for beer (no kidding) , german cars, the green, or they wanted to be with a German person they got to know somewhere. but instead of considering any other possibilities - the average German tends to assume "ah he wants our awesome healthcare & social security).

This needs to change. Especially if you want to tackle the fachkraftemängel. Those qualified people will get employed anywhere. The government gets this and has made small moves to make it "easier" - you can easily get a permit and work here now - this is good. Even the beauraucracy is less of a pain in the ass than a few years ago.

What's missing though is the public education. Merkel herself at some point said "Multiculti has failed in Germany". Foreigners will take an integrationtest, learn the language and even figure out the complicated regulation system. In turn though - you need to offer them more than juts a decent salary and standard of living - you need to offer them acceptance. This is missing. People need to be given reverse integrations training or atleast provided some information - let them understand that these people aren't here to mooch of the system or steal jobs - they're here because to a large extent the country needs them.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by rayiner on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @04:03PM (#6213857)
You cannot live an equally good life in the developing world. That's a romanticization. First, the top 1% of India has purchasing power equivalent to just above the median purchasing power in the U.S.[1] "Upper middle class" in India is defined as $10-20 international dollars per day.[2]

Second, even if you are top 1% in India living like a top 25% in Indiana, your life is one of walls and enclaves. My family was rich in the developing world. We would go from our house with its high wall and iron gate into our foreign car with driver and tinted windows. We would do anything we could to avoid having to interact with the people on the street, our supposed countrymen.

The US has its enclaves, but I can get in a car and head to the relatively poor coastal town where my wife's parents grew up. I can go eat at the seafood shack by the side of the highway and consider it a treat. I can talk to the people and feel like we all live in the same country. That's living a good life.

[1] See this article, for example: http://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/the-.... The couple in the article (one a consultant, another a PR executive) makes 1.8 million rupees per year, equivalent to about $29k USD. Adjusted for purchasing power (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity), that's roughly equivalent to $70-80k USD. That's roughly at the top 1/3 mark of US household income, and probably not that far above median for US households where both people are working. As noted in this article, the couple is well within the top 1% of India, which starts at $1.25 million rupees per year. That level is equivalent to about the 57th percentile in the U.S.

[2] http://www.dailymail.co.uk/indiahome/indianews/article-23271.... $20 PPP-adjusted dollars per day, or $7k/year is around the bottom 5% mark in the U.S. Only 4.6% of Indians have all four of these assets: a TV, a car or scooter, a landline or mobile phone, and a computer or laptop. Even people living in trailer parks in the U.S. will often have all four of these assets.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by raverbashing on Thursday August 15, 2013 @05:32AM (#6216867)
"You cannot live an equally good life in the developing world. That's a romanticization. "

Not really. You can't get as good in some aspects, but if you have the money (which is not difficult if you're being poached to work in Europe/the US) you can get beyond on some others.

Like big house with a pool and maids.

Very nice hotels/vacations for a price of an average hotel in Europe

"My family was rich in the developing world. We would go from our house with its high wall and iron gate into our foreign car with driver and tinted windows"

Spot on

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kamakazizuru on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:09PM (#6215046)
You missed the point - I´m not talking about the US. You might be able to find solidarity with the folks in your wifes towns seafood joint in the U.S. In Germany you'd at best get curious looks and awkward questions.

Everything else you've stated is either untrue (people lived in strange walled societies) or irrelevant (PPP etc - 29k is enough for people to live a good life in India. In any case the people I referred to - the ones who would even have a chance in places like Germany etc - are well above that 1% figure even in India). I leave it to you to figure out how big 1% of 1.2 Billion is.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by rayiner on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @07:32PM (#6215173)
> I´m not talking about the US. You might be able to find solidarity with the folks in your wifes towns seafood joint in the U.S. In Germany you'd at best get curious looks and awkward questions.

On the contrary, I think there is more solidarity across economic classes in most of Europe than there is in the U.S.

> Everything else you've stated is either untrue (people lived in strange walled societies)

They certainly do: http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/10/29/at-bangalores-gate....

> or irrelevant (PPP etc - 29k is enough for people to live a good life in India.

Sure, but your premise was that people didn't come to the West from places like India for the economic opportunities, because "a well qualified person can live an equally good life in the developing world as he would in Germany." A programmer in Germany lives a far better quality of life than his counterpart in India, at nearly any level of qualification.

> I leave it to you to figure out how big 1% of 1.2 Billion is.

It doesn't matter how many people are in the 1%--it still means that 99 out of 100 people live in far less comfortable circumstances. And, from my personal experience, living in communities with high income inequality sucks. I find it barely tolerable in Wilmington, DE, and that's a egalitarian paradise in comparison to anywhere in India. Life in India is not "equally good" outside the enclaves frequented by 1%-ers and Western expatriates, and being forced to stick to these enclaves is itself something that undermines quality of life.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kamakazizuru on Thursday August 15, 2013 @06:22AM (#6216998)
well being from what would be considered that 1% of india - I can assure you I didn't live in an enclave where I didn't have access to the "real world" around me.

Getting back to the actual point - quality of life is highly subjective and the fact that there's a strong reverse brain drain happening makes it pretty obvious that there's plenty good opportunities in India right now - educated Indians dont need to go abroad for a good life. Sure there maybe differences - but after a certain level it doesn't matter anyways. The truth is - there are more people in india (also proportionally) - who have access to a decent standard of living today - than there were at any point in its history - and for most Indians thats pretty good already.

More importantly - what you misunderstood by focusing on just that one statement is that - the economic difference is just not attractive enough that companies can ignore the softer aspects. Especially for a country like Germany where the language barrier is anyways a huge disadvantage - just being economically attractive isn't going to be enough for them to draw people in. In fact - a recent article from a leading german weekly itself states that even after simplifying the visa process (if you have a degree in STEM - you can essentially just come here for 6 months and look for work no questions asked) - there hasn't been any sort of significant increase in the number of qualified people coming here. Anecdotal and personal experience, as well as the numbers clearly then point out that even for people who would maybe want better economical conditions - there's other things that matter more.

When you lose yourself in the statistics and GDP calculations - you miss the bigger picture. People are fine with living with less money in places where they feel happy compared to places where they dont feel at home, especially if the difference in the money is not percieved to be significant enough.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by levosmetalo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:15AM (#6211998)
Immigration is really a major point. As an immigrant from south European country that moved to Germany with a plan to stay here with the already formed family, all I can say it's not that easy.

It's not only about giving the immigrant right to work, live, later vote in Germany. It's about absorbing them, making their life easier, and truly helping them to integrate into society. That's the effort that, right now, an immigrant has to make himself, but there's no much support from the state.

My own example, I came here on Blue Card. That was easy. Then, I had to wait for half a year before my wife and children could join me. Then we had to wait for another half year before my children could start with the kindergarten. Only after that, my wife could actually start going to language / integration course. All in all, a year wasted before we could even start integrating. In addition to that, my son will start school next year, and will have only one year at German kindergarten instead of two. That will severely impact his ability to actually attend school in a yet unlearned language.

What I want to say is that integration of immigrant is not easy, and there's much more that needs to be done. If you want them to integrate into the society, you should treat them much better, even better than citizen. Why? Because Germany needs them?

If it's not done properly, in 50 years there will be no more German way of life. Majority of the people will not know how to use "der", "die" and "das" properly and would not even care about that. Half of the German population will be made of non integrated immigrants, leaving in small communities of people with the same origin.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kamakazizuru on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:48PM (#6212594)
yes - this is exactly the point I made in my comment above. Couldnt agree with you more. Dont just make getting a visa or a job easy - make it easier for people to integrate - make people more accepted.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by currywurst on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:57AM (#6211867)
They are not happy with the way the last mass immigration (of the Turkish) turned out. But they have recently made a lot of concessions for in-demand skills like tech, nursing and so on.

And if you get a salary above a certain threshold, you even qualify for a "Blue Card" that allows you to work anywhere in the EU !

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by kamakazizuru on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @12:49PM (#6212611)
Its a good step. The problem though was never the visa or whatever. The problem was and continues to be the fact that Germans as a society have trouble accepting immigrants. The first assumption (probably because of bad experiences with turks) is that these people are here to mooch of the system and wont learn our way of doing things. Thats disastrously untrue - and only serves to make Germany unattractive.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by philipp-de on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:02AM (#6211910)
The terms of these initiatives (Fachkräfteinitiative, Blue Card) are so one sided and onerous that very few people from outside actually use them.

These initiatives, started years ago, so far have flopped.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by Cass on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:46AM (#6211789)
They actually created a new residency law designed to make immigration to Germany easier for skilled employees just a year ago. Google "blue card". It hasn't had the success they were hoping for, but they're trying.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by ultramundane828 on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:40AM (#6211758)
They mention that briefly, but yes, this was my initial thought as well. I'm sure there are plenty of people itching to fill the empty space.
Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by raverbashing on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @10:49AM (#6211814)
There are some initiatives towards that, like the German Blue Card

After 5 years in the country you can file for permanent residency.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by levosmetalo on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @11:21AM (#6212033)
Actually, as a Blue Card holder, you can file for permanent residency after 33 months. If you learn language to at least B1 level, you can file after only 21 months.

In addition to that, you partner automatically gets work permit without restriction, and you are eligible for all social benefits like health care and Kindergeld from the day one.

Compare that with the H1B / Green Card situation, and the contrast is clear. It was an easy choice for me (yes, I had job offers from both USA and Germany), and will probably attract more people in the future.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by raverbashing on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @01:24PM (#6212885)
Good

Not to mention it doesn't take almost a full year to get like the H1B

Getting B1 level in German should be not so complicated and attainable in, let's say, 18 months.

Re:Germany Fights Population Drop by levosmetalo on Thursday August 15, 2013 @07:19AM (#6217123)
Yes. They list a limit of 3 months just to be on the safe side, but nowadays it's usually granted in ~6 weeks.