Re:A skeptical response to Musk's hyperloop
by makomk on Wednesday August 14, 2013 @09:58AM
(#6211494)
What's wrong with this part?
> Tesla’s train energy consumption numbers do not pass a sanity check, which suggests either reckless disregard for the research or fraud. I wouldn’t put either past Musk: the lack of references is consistent with the former, and the fact that Musk’s current primary endeavor is a car company is consistent with the latter
If the blog post's claims are correct - and the numbers in it seem to have a much more solid basis in fact than anything Elon Musk's come up with - then even a simple back-of-the-envelope calculation should've been enough to show his power consumption figures for high-speed rail are impossibly high. The trains are simply incapable of using that much power.
> Tesla’s train energy consumption numbers do not pass a sanity check, which suggests either reckless disregard for the research or fraud. I wouldn’t put either past Musk: the lack of references is consistent with the former, and the fact that Musk’s current primary endeavor is a car company is consistent with the latter
If the blog post's claims are correct - and the numbers in it seem to have a much more solid basis in fact than anything Elon Musk's come up with - then even a simple back-of-the-envelope calculation should've been enough to show his power consumption figures for high-speed rail are impossibly high. The trains are simply incapable of using that much power.