Re:How phone batteries measure the weather
by JamesCRR on Tuesday August 13, 2013 @02:37PM
(#6207426)
Nice points,
We were told the paper would be published (and open access today) but doesn't quite seem to be up yet: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/grl.50786/abstrac...
The paper does have more detail, and I believe supporting materials will be released. You can also download the data and do some of your own digging (either from the big file at the bottom, or just view source and grab the js values that feed the graphs)
James,
did you guys consider (or try out) Eureqa [1] to get a good model for the estimate? It works very well with such kind of data.
As with all estimates I care about the error and not much else. The only error measure provided is mean absolute error which I find a little bit unsatisfying. It gives only very little information about the behavior of the error.
The easiest is to compute the error for every sample and then show a histogram of it.
Why you might wonder? In this case we deal with varying -though often over time stabalizing- data. This means that sometimes the error is actually greater and then very little. If you take the absoluate value of it and take the average (MAE), you might underestimate (resp overestimate) the error at times. In this case I might expect a tri-modal error distribution if we consider positive & negative errors.
A histogram is much more expressive (and oh so simple to generate) than a simple MEAN, STD DEV, MAE or MSE.