News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Is our criticism of surveillance not a bit hypocr... by jaachan on Monday August 12, 2013 @11:17AM (#6199650)
The bins article talked about things like "Installing a sensor in the bathroom so you know which gender the person has." Not to mention they'd connect things like which shops you visit and at what time. At any time a police officer could come along and say "We want all records you have on MAC address xx:xx". Quite a difference from websites tracking people.

The same problem exists with Google tracking - it's not that you know who's been to your site, it's that Google know every site you've been on, when you've been there, and what you did there.

Re:Ask HN: Is our criticism of surveillance not a bit hypocr... by AliAdams on Monday August 12, 2013 @11:24AM (#6199694)
If there was a good way for people to determine site visitor gender, I bet they would do that too.

I realise that the data is a bit more complete when you are looking at movement on the street, so an officer taking the data would have more 'useful' information than that acquired from a user visiting a website, but that surely doesn't mean that collection of such data is wrong?

It's like if an old lady sitting on a porch kept a tally of the genders of people walking down the street each hour - all you are doing is automating the old lady.

Re:Ask HN: Is our criticism of surveillance not a bit hypocr... by jaachan on Monday August 12, 2013 @01:06PM (#6200300)
"All you do is automate X"? But automating means you can do things at a much larger scale. Before if you'd want to track cars on a given road, you'd need to pay a few people to write down plates. Now you can keep track of every car in every street 24/7 almost without fail.

Automating is a big deal, it's not something that makes no difference.