News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What did Edward Snowden get wrong? Everything by LoganCale on Sunday August 11, 2013 @03:13PM (#6195864)
Propaganda-filled statist bullshit. Appeals to authority, and uses ridiculous examples to justify it.

> But I worry less about what happens to this one man and more about the damage Snowden has done — and could still do — to America's long-term ability to strike the right balance between privacy and security.

The only valid balance is 100% privacy. A government that violates its citizens' privacy is not acting legitimately.

> Ever since Snowden, a former contractor for the National Security Agency, leaked top-secret material about its surveillance programs, he and the U.S. government have locked horns about the nature of those programs.

He's trying to rephrase the story to be one of Snowden vs. the U.S. rather than the U.S. government vs. the people.

> Second, despite the grumbling from Snowden and his admirers, the U.S. government truly does make strenuous efforts not to violate privacy, not just because it respects privacy (which it does), but because it simply doesn't have the time to read irrelevant emails or listen in on conversations unconnected to possible plots against American civilians.

If it's archiving them, it has all the time in the world, and can search through them at later times and forward information to relevant agencies. And we already know this happens with the DEA and IRS, so his argument here is even more irrelevant.

> I know firsthand that Gen. Keith Alexander, the NSA director, is telling the truth when he talks about plots that have been preempted and attacks that have been foiled because of intelligence his agency collected.

It doesn't matter how many attacks they believe they have foiled, that doesn't justify dragnet surveillance. Nothing does.

> Let me break this to you gently. The government is not interested in your conversations with your aunt, unless, of course, she is a key terrorist leader.

Trying to sideline the issue by suggesting ordinary people only talk about irrelevant things. What about journalists, politicians, political activists, and people who commit victimless crimes? As noted in a fantastic article by Moxie Marlinspike, laws can't be overturned without people breaking those laws: drug laws won't be overturned without people breaking the laws and using the drugs and wanting them to be legal, etc.

> Unfortunately, during the Snowden affair, many news outlets have spent more time examining ways the government could abuse the information it has access to while giving scant mention to the lengths to which the intelligence community goes to protect privacy. We have spent enormous amounts of time and effort figuring out how to disaggregate the important specks from the overwhelming bulk of irrelevant data.

"Trust us. We have a policy." Not everyone is guaranteed to always follow that policy, and it's a secret policy, with no legitimate oversight.

Re:What did Edward Snowden get wrong? Everything by fixxer on Sunday August 11, 2013 @03:16PM (#6195881)
Absolutely. I'm so tired of these true believer bureaucrats telling me "it is all for my own good, and no, you can't know anything about it."
Re:What did Edward Snowden get wrong? Everything by thesteamboat on Sunday August 11, 2013 @03:25PM (#6195931)
And even if the government is sincere in everything its doing, (no privacy violations, no mission creep, etc.) do we have confidence that it can keep the stored data secure from criminals, crackers, foreign governments or other malicious entities?
Re:What did Edward Snowden get wrong? Everything by fixxer on Sunday August 11, 2013 @03:28PM (#6195946)
What is so mind boggling to me, beyond the double-speak, is how nobody on the government side acknowledges basic systematic risk. They assume their system is perfect and their people are impeccable... have they ever been the fucking post office or DMV?! Those are government employees!
Re:What did Edward Snowden get wrong? Everything by tzs on Sunday August 11, 2013 @06:09PM (#6196531)
> The only valid balance is 100% privacy. A government that violates its citizens' privacy is not acting legitimately.

What do you mean by "100% privacy"? For instance, are wiretaps authorized by a warrant from a district court OK, or do those violation your 100% privacy condition?

Re:What did Edward Snowden get wrong? Everything by Zigurd on Sunday August 11, 2013 @07:46PM (#6196884)
Modern crypto offers 100% privacy if you do it right. How would you enforce a court order to tap a conversation that's encrypted and the keys are discarded after use? It's tantamount to a court order to defy gravity. Sure, you can write such a document, and it might be constitutional to write such a document and you might even throw someone in jail for contempt for disobeying such an order. But... so what?
Re:What did Edward Snowden get wrong? Everything by malandrew on Sunday August 11, 2013 @09:52PM (#6197253)
At the end of the day whatever crime you are trying to get them for is occurring in the real world as well. All that physical evidence should help with convictions.

When there is a murder, there is a body. When there is a rape, there is a victim. When there is a robbery, there are stolen goods. When drug trafficking has occurred, there are drugs. When there is child porn, there is a child involved. When there is a network breakin, there are server logs. When there is drug or bomb manufacture, there are raw materials.

The police should be able to put people in jail based entirely on evidence of a crime without ever having to rely on anything a potential suspect has said or written. If that's the only way they can put someone away, I question how much of an actual crime has even occurred. If you can't come up with physical evidence, has society suffered enough harm for it to be even worth jailing that person?

If all the physical evidence is still not enough for a conviction, then get a warrant and observe everything you can about that person of interest the old fashioned way. Eavesdrop on them with bugs (but don't remotely activate a backdoor in a phone that shouldn't exist). Stake out police officers at their house. Do undercover work. etc.

Will some people get away with their crimes? Certainly. And that's okay. That's the cost society pays for their privacy. Police work is expected to be expensive. The cost of investigative work is something that provides checks and balances to abuse. A corrupt individual will have a very hard time hiding the misappropriation of police resources for political or personal reasons. If you need to stake out cops at a politicians house to get dirt on them to blackmail with, that probably won't happen. If you can just type an email into the system, then the barrier is so low to committing such an abuse and the likelihood of getting caught so low, that you can be sure that that abuse will happen.

Also, keeping the cost high ensures that only those people who actually are terrorists, like active members of Al Quada are investigated. Right now the bar for investigation is so low that there has been a massive re-categorization of many domestic groups such as Occupy WallStreet as terrorists to be surveilled.

I have absolutely no qualms with paying more taxes to hire more detectives as the alternative to making sure that we catch the terrorists. Having a high price to pay for investigations forces us as a society to ask the hard question of what we actually think is worth investigating and what is merely a nuisance for some that we can live with. Paying for those investigations with our privacy is entirely too high a cost.

Re:What did Edward Snowden get wrong? Everything by LoganCale on Sunday August 11, 2013 @09:52PM (#6197249)
I was being somewhat hyperbolic, though one part of me rejects any sort of wiretap.

But in practice I would be happy with the way things are supposed to be, where a warrant backed up by probable cause is required for each individual being targeted for surveillance, and it must be for a specific investigation only, not for dragnet searching in the hopes of finding something on them.