News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by pg on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @08:03PM (#619573)
When I look at the pictures of this house, I have something like the feeling you get when you start to drink a glass of water and suddenly realize you were really dehydrated.

I often feel it when I see handmade things. There's something missing in manufactured stuff. It's information poor.

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by electromagnetic on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @08:58PM (#619651)
My parent's own a 200+ year old house in France that has an amazing amount of tactile information held in it. To stick with the feel of the building we manually plastered the inside walls, which with exposed wooden beams in every room looks amazing.

Each wall is unique in how it settled, each beam is unique in the cuts. The original upstairs floor was beautiful as it was hundreds of solid beams of wood 30 feet long, sadly most of it had been affected by wood worm on the surface ( everything had been hit by wood worms on the surface but miraculously the density of the oak or something seemed to keep them out of the core).

While I like the convenience of manufactured products, they all lack the heart and soul that's held in a handmade product. Often they seem to be lacking in quality too, possibly due to the fact that it's the materials not the labor that now costs the most.

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by tjic on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @10:04PM (#619715)
> each beam is unique in the cuts

A few years ago I took a class on timberframing ... and part of the class was building a timber frame house.

There's a family that - RIGHT NOW - is sitting, eating, and sleeping feet away from beams that I hand planed and joints that I layed out, cut, and chiseled.

That's a pretty cool feeling.

There are also a handful of friends and family members who have peppermills and salad bowls in their kitchen, that they use every day, that I made on my lathe.

I'm a big fan of making stuff with your own hands. (I even took today off from work so that I could sharpen some of my bowl gouges and work on some projects in the shop).

I recommend that folks give it a shot.

(And now, the obligatory plug - although I swear that I didn't plan it when I started this post! - if you're thinking of picking up a craft and don't know where to start, check out my startup http://smartflix.com )

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by randallsquared on Thursday May 21, 2009 @09:11AM (#620362)
Last night, I disagreed with this, but wasn't sure why, so I didn't post.

One reason I prefer manufactured things to handmade things is that the manufactured ones seem "right" in a way that the handmade ones never really do. When I make something by hand, it's never really done, because I can always see imperfections and problems. When something is made by machine, even the imperfections and problems seem like part of it, rather than mistakes, because the machine (ideally) does the same thing every time. It appeals to my sense of completion.

Another reason to prefer manufactured things to handmade (or custom) things is precisely that there's less information associated. It's more relaxing -- less cluttered, in the same sense as the Stuff essay ( http://www.paulgraham.com/stuff.html ).

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by ryanwaggoner on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @08:23PM (#619612)
I agree, and while I think part of it is the organic nature of the subject, I also think some of that feeling comes from that fantastic quality of the photography. It just looks like a fairytale.
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by staunch on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @08:41PM (#619630)
Let's just say that if you sent a letter to that place addressed to B. Baggins it wouldn't be returned.
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by gdee on Thursday May 21, 2009 @05:05AM (#620120)
> It just looks like a fairytale.

Well applied HDR[1] does that to photography.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_dynamic_range_imaging

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by TomOfTTB on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @09:24PM (#619677)
I think you make an important point. It looks great but obviously the guy who built it had an eye for visual design and put a lot of effort into finding the exact right location. Duplicating his setup would be next to impossible.

Conceptually though you could take any old patch of land and build a log cabin with the same functionality and general feel of nature (first one that came up on google: http://www.lincolnlogs.com/askabe.html)

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by KWD on Thursday May 21, 2009 @09:54AM (#620431)
When looking at the design I immediately thought of a Yurt. I guess primarily due to the roof structure. In this case, he just built it into the ground.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yurt

There are actually several companies building modern yurts. It's one of those fleeting thoughts of escapism I often have that is about buying some land and putting a yurt on it.

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by JesseAldridge on Thursday May 21, 2009 @01:31AM (#619953)
Interesting. I get the same feeling when I look at pixel art as compared to 3D rendering: http://pixeljoint.com/pixels/new_icons.asp?ob=rating
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by ntoshev on Thursday May 21, 2009 @12:53PM (#620725)
There is more to it than being information-rich or information-poor. A pile of junk is information-rich, but it's not beautiful. It comes down to style and taste.

The house looks organic. Like it has been grown instead of built. Gaudi's buildings have the same style. I think there is a lot of appeal in the organic style, it's a pity it's so rare.

The computational properties of style are explored in Douglas Hofstadter's book "Fluid Concepts and Creative Analogies" (I recommend it to any hacker interested in aesthetics or cognitive science, but it is not an easy read):

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0465024750?ie=UTF8&tag=...

Interestingly, computers can eventually make an assembly line produce unique stylish (organic or otherwise) things. Fractal images are, after all, beautiful, even being totally regular. Certain amount of randomness can do wonders.

Of course computers are similarly supposed to enable mass customization for physical things which is probably more important economically, and it hasn't happened yet.

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by zackattack on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @10:10PM (#619726)
Manufactured stuff is "information poor"? What does that mean?
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by pg on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @10:13PM (#619733)
I mean in the information theoretic sense. A 3d representation of it would compress well.
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by euccastro on Thursday May 21, 2009 @08:05AM (#620267)
I don't think it's the amount of information that we crave. Traditional japanese living spaces would compress well, yet they look like personal, interesting places to inhabit. Conversely, a messy manufactured home is information rich, but I don't think it would quench your 'thirst' in the same way.

I think it's meaning we crave, and if we can get it with a better signal to noise ratio, that's more peace of mind for us.

That said, the 'noise' in the shape and texture of natural materials compresses away as generic texture. I think we have evolved to interpret that effortlessly in hardware. The noise of a waterfall can give us peace while the noise of traffic usually has the opposite effect.

More interestingly, we can selectively turn off this mechanism to appreciate natural shapes and textures in their full depth. A tree can be very information rich if we direct our attention to it, while at the same time it's easy to filter it out as 'ok, tree here' without further anxiety. A landscape typically has a lot of information in it, but if we can find a pattern that summarizes its overall shape, its beauty just hits us as something really simple, without need for intense attention or effort in interpretation.

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by pg on Thursday May 21, 2009 @02:10PM (#620841)
I wouldn't disagree that merely increasing information content is not enough. Adding noise would do that. But I think a lot of the reason traditional Japanese houses feel comforting is that they do not, in fact, compress well. Close up, they're not simple: in the textures of the natural materials, the details of the handmade joints, etc.
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by netsp on Thursday May 21, 2009 @08:22PM (#621357)
There seems to be some sort of difference though. A manufactured version of traditional Japanese houses would feel a lot closer to the handmade then a manufactured version of this hobbit house.
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by thras on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @11:56PM (#619856)
Christopher Alexander (the original design pattern guy) has a somewhat similar view. Except that he took four books to say it. The books are quite beautiful though.
Re:Building a house for under $5000 by kirubakaran on Wednesday May 20, 2009 @10:55PM (#619786)
"Bland"

[on applying lossy compression to pg's comments (parent and child of your comment)]

Re:Building a house for under $5000 by pg on Thursday May 21, 2009 @02:55AM (#620021)
Shallow might be better.