Re:This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories
by true_religion on Sunday August 11, 2013 @01:27PM
(#6195491)
I'm not seeing multiple inserts per page, and I checked their 'stub' pages as well. They only have GA in the head.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories
by integraton on Sunday August 11, 2013 @02:59PM
(#6195811)
_utm.gif is apparently requested 3 times with the same google analytics account id.
Re:This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories
by davidp on Sunday August 11, 2013 @03:33PM
(#6195967)
In Chrome's F12 tools I see three _utm.gif requests from the article itself. According to http://utmgifparser.appspot.com/, the three requests appear identical except for the "X10 data" ('utme'); not sure of the significance of that w.r.t. GA reporting. Any GA experts care to enlighten?
Re:This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories
by true_religion on Sunday August 11, 2013 @05:30PM
(#6196404)
_utm.gif is the generic way that Google Analatics communicates back with its servers---there's no rest API.
So if you're doing things like event tracking, without counting the event as a page view, then you'll still see another request to _utm.gif
They appear to have one normal _trackPageView call in the header, then one or more other calls coming from within minimized JavaScript files.
Here's one:
_gaq.push(["_trackEvent", e, t, n.toString(), parseInt(r, 10), !0])
This is the signature for _trackEvent _trackEvent(category, action, opt_label, opt_value, opt_noninteraction)
!0 evaluates to true in javascript so this event is marked as non-interactive, and thus doesn't count as an extra page view and won't be used in bounce-rate calculations.Presuming the other calls are identical, then their reported bounce rate should be correct.
Re:This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories
by integraton on Sunday August 11, 2013 @06:29PM
(#6196593)
Looking at the two additional requests, they do currently have the utmni parameter, marking them as non-interactive.
However, the top comment references Google Analytics events on scroll that don't appear to be there now. One of FastCo.Labs folks also made the following comment:
This made me curious as well. It turns out there was a
technical change made at around the same time that is
going to account for some of it. We're running an
experiment now and will update with results.
I don't see the update from him. Given all of this, I would guess that they were triggering events incorrectly and have since fixed it (the article is 3 months old).
Re:This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories
by irollboozers on Sunday August 11, 2013 @11:00PM
(#6197424)
That's extremely embarrassing.