News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Homes for Hackers gets a visit from the FBI by Oculus on Saturday August 10, 2013 @04:07PM (#6192463)
The whole argument behind this ruling is that at first the suspect talked and then stopped answering questions. Had the suspect not talked in the first place, then the 5th wouldn't have been voided, but since he did, it was.
Re:Homes for Hackers gets a visit from the FBI by tankbot on Sunday August 11, 2013 @12:56AM (#6193899)
So am I correct to assume that, according to this description and the other answer, that this falls under the 4th amendment and since the person in question initially answered questions they implicitly gave up this right and are thus accountable when they decide to stop talking?
Re:Homes for Hackers gets a visit from the FBI by jlgaddis on Sunday August 11, 2013 @06:17AM (#6194597)
The guy initially "cooperated" and answered questions and, at a certain point, finally just shut up and refused to speak anymore. It was ruled that the fact that he suddenly decided not to "cooperate" and became silent could be used against him.

I imagine the state arguing it to the jury similar to this: "Mr. Doe was helpful and cooperative at first and happily answered our questions. Then, when we asked him about <insert crime here> he stopped being cooperative and refused to answer any more of our questions. If he wasn't involved with <the crime>, why wouldn't he continue to cooperate?"

Re:Homes for Hackers gets a visit from the FBI by tankbot on Sunday August 11, 2013 @10:20PM (#6197327)
Seems like another reason to never start talking in the first place. Thanks!