Re:Why choosing Carnegie Mellon over Harvard?
by rayiner on Saturday August 10, 2013 @11:21AM
(#6191359)
I'd never advise someone to go to school for "academic rigor." In engineering world its often cover for bad teaching and "gotcha" exams. Moreover, nobody is impressed. If you decide halfway through that you'd rather do management consulting, nobody is going to value that 3.6 at CMU over that 3.8 at Harvard. Engineers won't value it because they want to see your work. Graduate programs want to see your publications and research proposal. The only ones who care about the signaling aspect of college will be the ones who don't value the extra rigor.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why choosing Carnegie Mellon over Harvard?
by hga on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:13PM
(#6191556)
Can't comment at all on whether CMU has bad teaching and "gotcha" exams, but I can say it means rather a lot if a CS student graduates from it, MIT, UC Berkeley or Stanford. Any of those are significantly better than Harvard in this one field; I'm also quite uncertain if Harvard has any outstanding engineering departments. The latter has long been a sore point between Harvard and MIT, especially after Charles Eliot followed a stint of chemistry at MIT with reforming Harvard into the powerhouse it is today. Even caused a street riot in 1904 or 5 (seriously).
Re:Why choosing Carnegie Mellon over Harvard?
by meowface on Saturday August 10, 2013 @12:34PM
(#6191646)
True, but in addition CMU probably has one of the best information security programs (and I'm sure various other comp sci-related programs) in the country. US-CERT originated there, and their CTF team is pretty much the best in the world.
So for example, if I were a manager hiring for a security position, I would probably place more weight in a CMU graduate than a random Ivy graduate.
I would also say it's probably not coincidental that they churn out very competent individuals and also are very academically rigorous. Sometimes theory and practice do align.
Re:Why choosing Carnegie Mellon over Harvard?
by joshu on Saturday August 10, 2013 @01:25PM
(#6191873)
"You have to have had at least a 3.5 GPA to work here. Oh, you went to CMU? You graduated? That's good enough" - interviewer I had at Goldman Sachs.
Re:Why choosing Carnegie Mellon over Harvard?
by hga on Saturday August 10, 2013 @02:17PM
(#6192063)
MIT addresses this by doing GPAs on a 5.0 scale: http://web.mit.edu/registrar/gpacalc.html