http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duverger's_law
If you want to build a viable third party, start with local elections, build your farm team. It takes decades to be viable. Then at some point, one of the dominate coalitions will pivot and subsume the new platform.
It's happened many times in the USA.
That means we do not really have a choice. The only solution is to vote third party until the Democrats get their act together, especially in the swing states -- we need to hit them where it hurts until they get their act together.
Sure. Punish them. Get it out of your system.
You do have a choice. You can organize. You can be the change that you want to see.
As a political acquaintance of mine likes to say: Whenever I feel the heat, I see the light!
If you don't know how to get started, I recommend Camp Wellstone's organizer training and joining your local political party (whatever flavor you like) and become a precinct committee officer.
...after the first four years, why would you vote for him again? It became clear almost from the first day of his presidency that his campaign promises were hollow.
Stop letting your fear that a Republican might win get the better of you. Vote third party until the Democrats get their act together.