News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bugger by steveklabnik on Friday August 09, 2013 @03:18PM (#6187766)
> Why not actually help us understand the useful aspects of continental philosophy?

Sorry, I thought you were trying to understand what Chomsky is saying here, not get an introduction yourself.

> You're after all assuming that the philosophy he criticizes is Haskell.

I'm not assuming; I've read most of these people, or at least have a basic grasp of their ideas.

> And why pick that one particular paragraph?

I thought it was the one that was most illustrative.

> How about the one where he mentions meeting some luminaries he criticizes, like Foucault, Derrida, and Kristeva?

Uhhh I replaced "Derrida, Lacan, Lyotard, Kristeva, etc. --- even Foucault," with "functors, arrows, hylomorphisms, monads, etc. --- even first-class functions". I'm not sure how I could more directly engage there.

> What about when he requests these philosophers [explain themselves]

They do. There is a wealth of introductory literature. I think you're taking Chomsky too literally here; this is rhetoric.

As an incredibly simple, basic introduction, here's an eight minute video on postmodernism and Community http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YanhEVEgkYI

And here's a 5 minute introduction to Zizek, who Chomsky has been reviving this spat with in the press as of late: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZDNhKBxgTw

Re:Bugger by calibraxis on Friday August 09, 2013 @03:40PM (#6187917)
> I'm not assuming; I've read most of these people, or at least have a basic grasp of their ideas.

Should you believe something I believe, merely because I claim it's right (with no evidence)? I likely believe some false things. People believe all sorts of weird things. The AI snakeoil salesman might believe in his own snakeoil.

> I'm not sure how I could more directly engage there.

By using the actual paragraph where he mentions actually meeting Foucault, Derrida, and Kristeva. Or in general, try peforming the same trick on a passage where your point maybe doesn't look so hot. Or instead of Haskell, the aforementioned AI snakeoil.

> There is a wealth of introductory literature.

Here, I cite introductory literature on a non-mainstream programming language, on many levels: (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6038989). It took work, but I hope it helped a couple people.

(It's unhelpful to merely cite the existence of literature (rather than naming it), leaving people ignorant. After all, I demonstrated that I was willing to re-read the Chomsky/Foucault discussion. I'm not lazy.)

And I vouch for the literature I cite. That means if people have problems with it, I know places where people can go and ask away to their heart's content. Or I will sit down and help people understand, until they're satisfied (or no longer interested).

[Edit: I see you edited to offer youtube links. Thanks, will watch! If they're good and in-depth, then ignore my last point.]

Re:Bugger by steveklabnik on Friday August 09, 2013 @03:54PM (#6188014)
Sorry, I really think we were talking past each other for a bit here. I misunderstood what you were actually asking for.
Re:Bugger by calibraxis on Friday August 09, 2013 @04:25PM (#6188222)
And sorry for misunderstandings on my part.