Re:DC, Maryland: Speed Camera Firms Move To Hide Evidence
by pdonis on Friday August 09, 2013 @09:51AM
(#6185588)
If you restrict the basis of decision-making to certainty rather than "estimated likelihood"
That's not what I said. I said that the law should not be able to impose punishment based on likelihood of harm, only based on actual harm. That has nothing to do with whether or not people should take into account likelihood of harm when making their own decisions; of course they should.
the limits there are not abnormally low because the legislators and bureaucrats are using unsound information, but because they intentionally ignore (or don't even bother acquiring) recommendations which indicate that a higher speed would be safe
Which is exactly what I have said elsewhere in these posts. In what you quoted, I was only pointing out that in fact, even if the legislators and bureaucrats were trying to set the "right" speed limits; they can't, because they can't possibly have all the relevant information. So the common belief that the legislators and bureaucrats are "helping to keep the roads safe" by setting speed limits is wrong in two ways: (1) that's not their real motivation; and (2) they're not capable of doing it anyway.
That's not what I said. I said that the law should not be able to impose punishment based on likelihood of harm, only based on actual harm. That has nothing to do with whether or not people should take into account likelihood of harm when making their own decisions; of course they should.
the limits there are not abnormally low because the legislators and bureaucrats are using unsound information, but because they intentionally ignore (or don't even bother acquiring) recommendations which indicate that a higher speed would be safe
Which is exactly what I have said elsewhere in these posts. In what you quoted, I was only pointing out that in fact, even if the legislators and bureaucrats were trying to set the "right" speed limits; they can't, because they can't possibly have all the relevant information. So the common belief that the legislators and bureaucrats are "helping to keep the roads safe" by setting speed limits is wrong in two ways: (1) that's not their real motivation; and (2) they're not capable of doing it anyway.