News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon's profits by dnautics on Thursday August 08, 2013 @07:47PM (#6182761)
could someone explain the marxism thing to me? I'm really scratching my head on this. Certainly it's not his labor theory of value. Is it supposed to be an analogy to "From those who can provide to those who need it"??
Re:Amazon's profits by jlgreco on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:41PM (#6182986)
Karl Popper is most famous for his work in the theory of science; primarily the importance of falsifiability. Apparently he had an issue with Marxism because he felt it wasn't falsifiable. The idea is that it should be possible in theory to prove any good theory wrong. For example, the theory of evolution is a good theory because there are things that we could discover that could prove it wrong (Precambrian rabbits).

Marxism is not really what I would pick to talk about Karl Popper and falsifiability... his writings on politics are pretty much a side-act. I am guessing the author was recently reading some of Karl Popper's more political writings. I would have picked psychoanalysis.

Re:Amazon's profits by jfb on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:45PM (#6183422)
I don't think Marxism was Popper's side act, particularly later in life (The Open Society And Its Enemies, The Poverty Of Historicism). Marxism and Freudianism were targets of Popper's because they appropriate the language of science for what he argued were in fact non-sciences.

It's important to remember that in the '20s, Marxism was presented as a scientific theory, that it described a logical, teleological process by which human society could be perfected. This was the Popper's later great white whale. Ask George Soros!

Re:Amazon's profits by btilly on Friday August 09, 2013 @12:51AM (#6183821)
An amusing fact about Karl Popper is that he also rejected quantum mechanics as a valid scientific theory because no probabilistic theory can be falsified.

The irony is that the standard methods of hypothesis testing which are often used to test statistical theories, including quantum mechanics, is based on reasoning with strong parallels to Popper's theory of falsifiability.

It is worth noting that Popper's theory is itself false. Real scientists do not simply throw away a theory because it is proven false. Good theories are hard to find. And a false theory may still be a useful approximation!

Re:Amazon's profits by dnautics on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:47PM (#6183003)
oh, I see. There's a seriously flawed parallelism in his list; the first is a direct analogy (between GE and amazon itself) and the second is an analogy about analogies made on amazon.
Re:Amazon's profits by leod on Thursday August 08, 2013 @07:59PM (#6182819)
It certainly struck me as an odd analogy. There are plenty of theories that are hard to disprove, why choose one as politically loaded as "Marxism"?
Re:Amazon's profits by jfb on Thursday August 08, 2013 @08:55PM (#6183029)
Nevermind this, I misread the parent. Yeah, it's a bit odd. Certainly, Popper's black/white swan analogy would've been sufficient.
Re:Amazon's profits by ser0 on Thursday August 08, 2013 @09:12PM (#6183091)
I think the author was just trying to avoid the other, perhaps more controversial, unfalsifiable analogy, which relates to faith based theories (I don't want to offend anyone either).

I agree that the Marxist part at the end disrupts the flow of the article. The article would have been better served if it kept within a financial analysis context.

Re:Amazon's profits by steveklabnik on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:14PM (#6183283)
I found it especially funny in light of an article I was reading this morning: http://plover.net/~bonds/positivism.html