Re:IRS manual detailed DEA's use of hidden intel evidence
by gyepi on Thursday August 08, 2013 @10:10AM
(#6178983)
Good try, but these won't wash. It's hard to argue against it because the facts seem quite clear and straightforward.
1. If the origin of the investigation is revealed to be illegal, the entire investigation is thrown into question and the resulting evidence could be suppressed.
2. Random traffic stops are illegal. There must be a reason for every stop.
https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/531/32/case.html
There will be some contention over whether investigators lied or simply didn't share all evidence. This will probably lead to some slippery wordplay. For example, in the case of a "random" traffic stop that was actually targeting an individual, the word "random" could be stretched to mean "without reason" - meaning that by saying it was a "random" traffic stop, investigators were really just not giving a reason for the stop. Since no reason is required for a random traffic stop (under this new definition), that's all fine.
Perhaps the real problem here isn't that the NSA was sharing information, but that it is easy to find probable cause when properly motivated.