News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This Startup’s Cheap Sensors Could Create an OS for Every... by solistice on Wednesday August 07, 2013 @05:56PM (#6175929)
I personally think this thing will be misused to the hilt, but there are ways they can add real value to a brick and mortar shopping experience.

Imagine you walked into a larger store, for example Walmart. As you walk in, the estimote app loads the wallmart app temporarily over the instore wifi. The app shows you a map of the store, which shows what products can be bought in which aisle, making your shopping experience much faster. As you approach the cash register, it acts like a concierge and tells you which register is the fastest one (some airports do this with a dedicated person, which directs people to different lines. It yields considerable speed ups). As you leave the store, the walmart app is removed from your phone. Estimote now shows you the nearest estimote enabled stores.

That's the good scenario. Now to the bad.

You go to the mall. As you approach it, you phone starts buzzing like it's mad. You think it's a call, so you pick up your phone. Nope, its Footlocker trying to sell you their new line of shoes at a 10% discount. Fine, but you're not looking for shoes. As you walk through the mall, your phone goes of wantonly, displaying ads for stores that are on the other side of the mall. Obviously, they don't know how to configure their estimotes. You can't walk for 5 meters without an estimote alert going off, logging itself to your allready estimote infested task list. Completely pissed off, you turn off your phone in order to leave the mall at peace. You're not buying stuff here. As you get home, you get an important call, but your phone is off, and you miss it. Resignated, you trash your iphone and get yourself a single purpose nokia. Serves you right estimote, serves your right.

I think there's certainly potential behind these, but their "sell the dev packs" approach to it doesn't seem to be very promising. Most small retailers will struggle with the setup and SDK. Hell, the local supermarkets cash registers here have SQL injection vunerabilities. One bar code that includes ;DROP TABLE * in it and they're closed for a week.

There seem to be several steps in setting these up. 1. Buying them. 2. Setting them up physically. 3. ? Linking them to a central system ? 4. Writing an app.

Out of these points, it seems they are only covering 1, even though there's certainly work involved (and money to be made) in steps 2 - 4 . Dumping these on the buyer leads to friction in the buying process which will cost them sales. They need to sort that out.

Re:This Startup’s Cheap Sensors Could Create an OS for Every... by aflinik on Thursday August 08, 2013 @02:18AM (#6177584)
Vendors using Estimote beacons will use the SDK to make entirely independent apps available in the App Store.

Only the specific apps that you choose to install will be able to communicate with particular beacons, so if one starts to annoy you with spammy behaviour you can easily remove it from your phone and forget about it.

Re:This Startup’s Cheap Sensors Could Create an OS for Every... by solistice on Thursday August 08, 2013 @07:26AM (#6178250)
Installing yet another app is friction though, and unless that app comes up with some serious punch, I doubt it'll be worth it for a lot of people. I think the physical browser model would work be a lot more convenient.
Re:This Startup’s Cheap Sensors Could Create an OS for Every... by aflinik on Thursday August 08, 2013 @12:14PM (#6179853)
Some retail companies (let's say barnes&noble) already have mobile apps. All it takes is to add beacon-related features, and their customers won't have to do anything.
Re:This Startup’s Cheap Sensors Could Create an OS for Every... by solistice on Thursday August 08, 2013 @03:42PM (#6181333)
Yeah, but individual apps on a screen is the very desktop model that we're increasingly moving away from. You have some special purpose programs (games, tools) on your computer, and most services have moved to the internet. Imagine you had to download a hacker news exe, and a google exe, and a reddit exe, etc.

By making customers download individual apps, your product becomes harder to implement/less profitable for stores which do not have an app with broad customer adoption. That makes you miss out on the long tail, which in this case could be considerable.

The locationally dependent browsing over in store wifi doesn't have this downside. It could leverage exsisting web technology, which makes the development off these apps a lot easier. It might work like this:

1. You walk into the beacon range. The beacon sends you the url: int.somestore.com/locationx?val=123094&locationy?val=594952&locationz=40389 2. It sends you the connection data for the internal wifi which serves up the stores webapplication. 3. The webapp is shown in the estimote app. 4. Profit.

Re:This Startup’s Cheap Sensors Could Create an OS for Every... by jimiasty on Friday August 09, 2013 @02:24AM (#6184038)
Thanks guys for the discussion, this is Jakub, the co-founder.

When it comes to the signal/noise problem it is definately a challenge and we believe that neither App Stores nor Estimote as beacons' infrastructure will allow apps that annoy consumers because it will kill the technology and users will turn off the Bluetooth.

Our vision of future interactions is more about context. We believe the cocept of apps you have to download and place as an icon on your screen and then find when you need is wrong.

It should work the way that you walk-in to the your home approache fridge with smartphone or Google Glass and wanted order for eggs, you take out your phone and there is a fridge context.

You walk-in to the restaurant and there is a context of menu and ordering food. You ate and there is a context of payin the bill, you walk-out and in the exit there is a conxtext of rating the restaurant.

So, in our vision future apps will be a set of conditions and actions you write for the venue the same way you do it now for the screen and keyboard.

From technology point of view if some popular app like Foursquare integreta with our beacons it could trigger other apps even if they not have our code yet, but there is a context for that.