The processing rate is typically lower because of agreements between issuing banks and debit processing networks, and is a somewhat hot topic at the moment as technically pinless online debit transactions are only intended for when the customers identity has been "confirmed", such as individuals with running accounts at a wireless carrier.
However, for whatever reason, some big companies are being allowed to use the MasterCard Debit/Maestro/Visa Debit/STAR/PULSE networks in this manner. In this case that company is Starbucks.
I'd estimate the rate paid by Amazon/Starbucks for processing pinless debit is 0.8% or less. Compare this with the 0.9 - 2.2% interchange fee (depending on card type) they'd incur if they processed these transactions as credit. It might not sound like a lot, but at that scale it probably ends up being millions per day saved.
There already seems to be a big moral hazard problem with credit card companies and merchants, where the merchants have to cover the entire loss if I understand correctly.
I'm hoping competition from startup payment processors might put pressure on credit card companies, as this ends up costing businesses and consumers a lot of money.
In my experience, most database breaches result in data being sold, not used. It's more profitable and results in far less risk (Ex: 100k cards @ $2/ea via anonymous payment methods) vs attempting to use the cards.
As such, the people who end up actually creating the transactions are usually low level individuals whom are trying to figure out a way to "cash out"
Not to say there isn't a chance you're right, but card data is cheaply and readily available elsewhere, which is why I don't think this was related to a phishing attack. If there were other signs (ex: bank logins compromised, credit inquiries, etc.) then I'd be much more inclined to agree. Either way, it's hard to come to a certain conclusion based on the information provided in the article.
I had a fraud issue caught by a bank once. What's strange is they caught the test at a bar I had frequented. That made me assume that it was skimmed. (But perhaps they saw many others tested there?)
Additionally, cost benefit wise, card data sells for $2-3 max, while track data sells for much much more ($25-50), and typically someone capable of acquiring this data themselves would not be wasting their time with Starbucks card reloads.
Who cares about gift card fraud when they are laundering billions for criminals, cartels etc.
If you get too much oversight, they might accidentally find all the other crap banks are upto.
If there is any institution you can be assured of fraud; it's banks.
Also, typically these are not "actual" (card-present, pin entered) debit transactions. Starbucks, much like Amazon, authorizes some online purchases as pinless debit card transactions, due to the lower processing rate incurred by the merchant. This can all be done completely online, for example, via Starbucks Online Reload system.[1]
This is truly nothing new, Gift card fraud has been booming since 2006-2007, when companies (starting with Starbucks, followed by Subway, Walmart[2], Whole Foods, etc.) began offering reloads to existing cards. Unfortunately, most of these companies have laughably bad fraud detection.
For example, Whole Foods uses a platform formerly known as "Giftango", which was rebranded as "InComm" in the last couple weeks. They quite literally will let a credit card thief reload hundreds of dollars from an IP anywhere in the world, to any gift card powered by their platform. No fraud scoring, velocity checks, geolocation, etc. You can imagine how easy this would be just by taking a look at their default gift card management portal, used by Whole Foods.[3]
Conveniently for credit card theives, WalMart even offers an option to reload a spreadsheet, or a CSV list of cards off a single credit card, easy right?[4]
Overall, I think this problem is only going to grow, especially with Cardpool acquired by Safeway, and now offering instant cash for gift cards in stores. This is an extremely easy method to cash out these fraudulently created gift cards, conveniently located at your local grocery store.
[1] https://www.starbucks.com/card/reload/one-time
[2] http://www.walmart.com/cp/Reload-Gift-Card/1097444
[3] https://app.giftango.com/GiftCardPortal/WholeFoods/GiftCardP...
[4] http://www.walmart.com/cp/Reload-Gift-Cards/416242