If you can't even see the screen of the phone you're booting then how does it matter if the rest of the kernel is Free or not?
A lot of the theory of optimization can be reduced to speeding up parts of code actually being executed and paging out parts of the code never actually touched, which works because the source is not uniformly useful. A kernel would be useless without a scheduler, a GUI program would be useless without an event loop, no matter how "open" the code surrounding those are.
Yet I can go to www.cyanogenmod.com and pull and build a tree for the One and boot it, with access to the source code for virtually all of the system (sans things like the GPU blob in question).
That you would argue this is no more open than iOS or Windows is weird, and sounds more like a stand on vain principle and not "pragmatism".
Is it bad? Yes. Is it equally bad? Hell no.