What if property rights were "packet switched" instead of "circuit switched"? (1)
We're still at the stage where our modems whistle at each other when it comes to "property". The future is going to be positively sci-fi.
(1) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circuit_switching#Compared_to_d...
That seems to be the preventing mechanism of "packet switched", unless people have liquid capital to be able to buy and sell large properties.
but they didn't price in the risk of technological innovation like AirBNB.
the corner stone in your logic (and in modern economy) is property rights. With my background (USSR), i'm used to think of property rights not of as something God given, instead as of something that was invented at some point and has been very useful so far in the development of our civilization. The property rights itself has evolved, from slavery societies to the modern day, from people as a property to ideas and RF spectrum being considered as property. The property rights will continue to evolve, and probably, God forbid - my townhouse is well over-water now, real estate rights disappear, while rights for DNA or human soul(mental footprint, dreams, etc..), something like this will come, or one day property rights, as exclusive license on something, will just stop being useful for human civilization at all.
Actually that's what they did, since residential usage like AirBNB is generally against zoning in these areas.
And you're focused on the selfish aspects of property rights without considering the benefits towards the commons they can confer, like keeping quiet residential areas quiet residential areas rather than high-traffic transient areas just because someone threw up a website.
you're missing my point that property rights and laws(zoning) change with (in response, forced by) technological development and innovation.
>And you're focused on the selfish aspects of property rights without considering the benefits towards the commons they can confer
again, my point was that specific property rights have their time when they are actually helping advancing the civilization, yet they are meaningless before their time and delay progress after.
As AirBNB helps more fully utilize buildings, it seems it is a plus for civilization and the laws/zoning preventing effective use of resources start to become obstacles in the way of progress.
Sharing is something different. Sharing involves concurrent use of resources mediated by tort-like systems, rather than property-like systems. A real "sharing economy" in cars might be what you end up when cars become self-driving. You won't own a car, but will use whichever car is nearby, and the law will punish various relevant anti-social behaviors instead of violations of property rights.
This distinction is very relevant to things like Uber or AirBnB, because the regulatory challenges there are various issues attached to property rights (e.g. zoning restrictions attached to houses, monopoly privileges attached to taxi medallions).
I agree with Genachowski that state and local governments are a battleground for innovation, but he makes it seem simpler than it is. It's not just a matter of preventing local governments from enacting laws that restrict innovation. It's more basic: renegotiating various privileges that have been negotiated into and priced into property rights. E.g. for better or worse, those who own cab medallions bargained for the monopoly they have, and gave up certain things in the process. Municipalities bargained to create telephone monopolies to serve rural areas instead of building infrastructure themselves. People who bought houses in residential neighborhoods did so pricing in the fact that those neighborhoods would not host hotels. Everyone thought these were reasonable policies at the time. Upsetting those settled expectations in property rights is going to be a very complicated process.
E.g. my personal regulatory interest is in spectrum sharing technology (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open_spectrum). Technology is getting close to the point where real "sharing" should be possible in radio spectrum. Not just fine-grained subdivision of property rights, but concurrent use mediated by tort-like mechanisms of enforcing "sociable" behavior. I think that technology needs to be rolled out all over the TV bands and the cellular bands. But it's not just a simple matter of flipping a switch. Verizon and AT&T paid billions for their spectrum, under the assumption that there would be nobody else playing in it. You have to kind of see their point of view in opposition to measures to enable sharing on their property. Same for all of the TV companies. They didn't pay for their spectrum, but they made tremendous investments based on certain assumptions, and they've got a right to question changes to those settled expectations.
Incidentally, this is not a new problem. The whole point of property rights is to settle expectations. When the situation changes dramatically, either because of technological or sociological changes, it is a political challenge to accommodate that change without trampling over those settled expectations.