News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by pessimizer on Monday August 05, 2013 @05:44PM (#6163323)
The point being made here is that isn't what conspiracy theories are. Conspiracy theories are about shadowy unknown cabals who create secret plans and execute them. They're not necessarily wrong, just usually.

You're equating leaps of logic with conspiracy theories. For example, saying "crystal power cured my cancer" is a leap of logic.

Saying that there's probably a consortium of Big Pharma, government officials and diamond mining companies who create astroturf groups that are tasked with publicly ridiculing crystal power in the popular press is a conspiracy theory.

It's not stupid because it's a conspiracy theory, it's stupid because it's stupid.

Wondering if Michael Hastings, a muckraking journalist who was claiming to have new muck who also died under strange circumstances may have been murdered, that's speculation. Speculating that this was the result of a secret plan hatched by more than one person would be a conspiracy theory. All should be judged on their merits.

Putting the possibility that a journalist may have had his car bombed on the credibility scale with "troofers" and fake Moon landing people is bizarre, though. I'm pretty sure that a journalist somewhere got murdered today to make sure he/she didn't report on something. It happens all of the time.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by jlgreco on Monday August 05, 2013 @05:57PM (#6163405)
"It's not stupid because it's a conspiracy theory, it's stupid because it's stupid."

I'd say that an "anti-crystal" conspiracy is stupid not because it is stupid (which is just a tautology) but rather because there is no actual evidence for it. In order to not be written off as a "crazy conspiracy theory", you are going to need more than weak circumstantial evidence on par with newspaper clippings haphazardly pinned to a wall with spiderwebs of red yard.