News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by mikeash on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:21PM (#6162670)
HN just wouldn't be the same without a conspiracy theory on the front page.
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by patrickg_zill on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:49PM (#6162918)
LIBOR manipulation, PRISM, FBI deliverately poisoning alcohol during Prohibition Tuskegee Syphilis Study

all believed to be just "crazy conspiracy theories" and now proven to be the case.

In the case of LIBOR, anywhere from a few hundred to a couple thousand people kept the secret of the manipulation for about 10 years - it only came to light due to a slightly-related investigation of one of the banks involved.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by mikeash on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:52PM (#6162935)
They laughed at Einstein, but they also laughed at Bozo the Clown.

Maybe this crash was an assassination. But if you want to not be called a conspiracy nut, you need evidence to back it up. So far there is none.

Without evidence, there's no way to distinguish between something like LIBOR and the idea that Apollo 11 was filmed on a Hollywood sound stage.

So far, every single article on this guy's crash has been of the fake moon landing genre, not the LIBOR genre.

Maybe it happened. But as long as people keep posting conspiracy theories about it, I'm going to keep calling them exactly that.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by adventured on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:29PM (#6162742)
What conspiracy? The US Government has the authority to assassinate US citizens.

I don't see how speculation about the circumstances of Hastings death need involve much of a conspiracy theory. It's not like we're talking about JFK here.

His life was directly threatened over and over again due to his previous writings; and it was threatened by someone close to McChrystal.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by patrickg_zill on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:51PM (#6162933)
A "nit" ...

the US Government "claims" to have the authority to assassinate US citizens.

My view of the Constitution says the US Gov't does NOT have the authority to execute someone without a trial.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by dailyrorschach on Monday August 05, 2013 @05:21PM (#6163152)
I think its important to say what is actually being claimed. In the case of al-Awaki(Aulaqi) their claim is:

"Such considerations allow for the use of lethal force in a foreign country against a U.S. citizen who is a senior operational leader of al'Qaida or its associated forces, and who is actively engaged in planning to kill Americans, in the following circumstances: (1) the U.S. government has determined, after a thorough and careful review, that the individual poses an imminent threat of violent attack against the United States; (2) capture is not feasible; and (3) the operation would be conducted in a manner consistent with applicable law of war principles."

With regard to the other three citizens that have been killed in a drone strike, their claim is that these individuals were not specifically targeted and were collateral damage.

The document (http://www.justice.gov/slideshow/AG-letter-5-22-13.pdf) does place emphasis on foreign country. So while not making any value judgement on the policy, I think its useful to see it in full, as currently understood.

One interesting corollary to look at is the Civil War, where U.S. citizens took up arms against their government and were killed by the government, where no declaration of war took place.

This is gotten tangential, but all I'm saying is current claims the U.S. has made do not seem to extend to extra-judicial killing of targets not engaged in active warfare on U.S. soil.

Edited: to add quotation marks.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by mpyne on Monday August 05, 2013 @05:22PM (#6163166)
So if there was one American serving in the Wehrmacht, or the Kriegsmarine, or the Luftwaffe during WWII, the U.S. government's military would have had no authority to shoot back at him without a trial first?
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by adventured on Monday August 05, 2013 @05:45PM (#6163329)
False context. The discussion is around domestic assassination (specifically of an unarmed journalist), not world war or war on a battlefield. Radically different concepts historically both from a legal and constitutional stand point. Your example couldn't be further away from the issue of assassinating an unarmed, non-threatening US citizen (whether domestic or overseas).
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by mpyne on Monday August 05, 2013 @08:22PM (#6164096)
Wait, who are we talking about now? You can't seriously mean that al-Awlaki is "an unarmed journalist"?
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by adventured on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:56PM (#6162962)
I prefer your interpretation. Better: they have the extraconstitutional ability to execute someone without trial.
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by mikeash on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:33PM (#6162777)
The circumstances of the crash are perfectly consistent with it being an accident, and every single article I've seen that says otherwise checks off every box of the Conspiracy Theorist Checklist (or it would if such a thing existed).

I'm going to need something more than "the USG could have assassinated him". Because even in the current climate, even with the threats, an accident is still the best explanation until shown otherwise. And none of the articles have come anywhere close to showing otherwise.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by adventured on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:39PM (#6162827)
I didn't say the USG did assassinate him. I said they have the authority to.

What I have said however, is that Hastings was threatened with death repeatedly for his writings. I wouldn't find it the least bit surprising if someone did make an attempt on his life.

Indeed, I don't think the USG would bother with an official assassination of someone like Hastings. There are plenty of dark characters available for that type of simplistic grunt work. For example, the guy associated with McChrystal that directly threatened to murder Hastings.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by mikeash on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:50PM (#6162923)
You asked me, what conspiracy? And the answer is, the conspiracy theory that this crash was an assassination by the US government.

You may not find it surprising if someone attempted to kill him. I may not find it surprising either, I don't know. But what I do know is that nothing revealed about this particular case so far points toward an assassination, and all of the articles about it posted on HN have approached the crash with a conspiracy mindset, where they twist fairly mundane facts to try to support the idea that it was, in fact, an assassination.

Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by Andrew_Quentin on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:39PM (#6162829)
When did suspicion become a conspiracy theory?
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by mikeash on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:47PM (#6162896)
When you support that suspicion with wild interpretations of mundane facts, as every linked article on the subject that I have read so far has done.
Re:Michael Hastings - 911 callers and new video confirm larg... by mikeash on Monday August 05, 2013 @08:30PM (#6164134)
I'm getting a lot of replies that are confused as to just what a conspiracy theory is, so I thought it would be worth following up to elaborate on that.

People seem to think that a conspiracy theory is about what is being theorized. The moon landing was faked. 9/11 was an inside job. The NSA is recording every American phone call.

But that's not it at all. It's not about what you theorize, it's about how. A sane and considered theory that leads to a crazy-seeming conclusion is not a conspiracy. Similarly, an insane theory that leads to a correct conclusion is still a conspiracy theory.

Some examples. Saying that the moon landing was faked because the flag was "fluttering" and there are no stars in the photographs is a conspiracy theory. Saying that the moon landing may have been faked because, say, you managed to get ahold of a secret memo from JFK discussing the possibility of faking it, would not be a conspiracy theory.

Similarly, saying that the NSA is spying on everybody because of the testimony and documentation provided by a whistleblower is not a conspiracy theory. However, saying that the NSA is spying on everybody because all the numbers in your e-mail header add up to 666 is a conspiracy theory.

What it comes down to is how you interpret the evidence. If you interpret it sanely, then it's not a conspiracy theory. If you twist mundane things to build narratives that are not justified by the evidence, then it's a conspiracy theory.

That is what's happening with this story. Is it possible that this person was assassinated by the US government? Sure. Is that theory supported by the evidence discussed by this article and other similar articles posted to HN over the past few weeks? Not even a little bit. And that, not the supposed outlandishness of the conclusion, is what makes this a "conspiracy theory" that is not worth paying attention to and frankly not worth making it to the front page of HN.

If an article on this matter shows up that sanely analyzes the evidence and comes up with the conclusion that it was probably an assassination, I'd love to see it on the front page. So far, this has not appeared.