News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by badclient on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:25PM (#6162311)
A little birdy says that "Submit" is the worst possible copy you could use for that button

Aren't you being too literal here? Vast majority of internet users have been trained to see "submit" for "okay I'm done filling out this form, next!".

Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by patio11 on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:38PM (#6162408)
We have competing hypotheses about an observable future fact. We should resolve them via the scientific method.

But if you don't have an email form doing thousands of impressions and want to just bet on this one, your bet would be a very bad bet to make.

Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by badclient on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:55PM (#6162507)
While I won't disagree that there might be other labels that perform better than "Submit", calling "submit" as the worst possible copy seems overtly sensational. We both know it isn't.
Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by mattangriffel on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:45PM (#6162879)
@dxm, haha I actually want to try "don't submit". That one may backfire and actually work better.
Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by dxm on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:44PM (#6162864)
It was too literal. "Don't submit" would definitely be worse, but still not the worst possible copy.
Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by rmc on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:56PM (#6162513)
Do an A/B test. What if you're wrong?
Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by mattangriffel on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:45PM (#6162875)
He's likely right, it's a best practice that may be wrong in some cases. Though generally, you're better off going with a best practice and then A/B testing alternatives.

The reality is that you're limited in the number of A/B tests you can do, both by traffic but also by your own time and resources. So you can run a test against something that is generally accepted (like what text works on a button) or against more important changes like headline copy or page layout.

Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by timr on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:50PM (#6162920)
What makes you think it's a best practice? It may be usual, but when it comes to getting people to notice (and therefore, do) things on the web, "usual" isn't usually that good.

The rest of your comment is a straw man fallacy. Of course you can't test everything. But, you know...it might just be reasonable to test the conversion button on your landing page, especially when someone who does a lot of testing tells you that it has a big impact. Because that's a more informative prior than "we should just use the default behavior".

Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by mattangriffel on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:58PM (#6162980)
point well taken, timr
Re:One Month Rails (YC S13) Teaches How To Build Your Startu... by rmc on Tuesday August 06, 2013 @04:41AM (#6165476)
you're better off going with a best practice

No-one ever got fired for buying IBM.