News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by marze on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:05PM (#6162179)
In deciding what to build next, you would compare nuclear with the other future options, which do not include coal.

No one argues that solar or wind will kill anyone.

And, the real problem with nuclear is that it isn't cost effective. If the free market was operating, no plants nuclear plants would be built in the US. It is only with govt. subsidies making 90% the up-front cost risk-free there has been even a nibble of interest from free market investors. And even that interest has petered out.

Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by jlgreco on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:05PM (#6162573)
If you were charged with building a city from scratch (unlikely, I know) and had to power the thing, the question wouldn't be "nuclear or solar/wind?". It would still be "Is this near a good damming location? No? So... do I want nuclear, or do I want to burn something?"

For renewable base load, your options are basically hydro or burning something renewable like ((farmed) wood, trash, or methane from trash). Otherwise, with current technology, you are left with either burning atoms or burning something made of dinosaurs that you claw from the earth.

Solar and Wind might be able to do some limited base-load with massive efficient energy storage schemes, such as pumped-storage hydro, but really I don't see that scaling very far. PSH is about as good as it gets for that, and it is highly dependent on local geography.. Other schemes like storing molten sodium or compressed air don't really operate in the same class as PSH.

Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by VLM on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:12PM (#6162220)
We no longer have a capitalistic free market in the USA, so its kind of irrelevant. Crony capitalism all the way. We just built a govt subsidized coal plant about 30 miles east (thankfully downwind) from my house. Wind plants don't run on wind but on govt subsidies. This kind of massive corruption makes engineering decisions kind of difficult, given that the bean counting numbers are pretty much imaginary.
Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by api on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:15PM (#6162635)
We've never had a free market. Perhaps we should, but so far it's never existed.
Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by danielweber on Monday August 05, 2013 @06:26PM (#6163563)
Solar and wind do kill people. You can't build a lot of large things without people dying.

No one in the US is building new coal because natural gas is super cheap these days. Market conditions can change, though.

Plus, China.

Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by neonhomer on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:20PM (#6162272)
But if the free market was truly operating would we be building any wind and solar plants? When it comes down to it aren't coal plants still the most economical from a market stand-point?
Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by VladRussian2 on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:11PM (#6162612)
>aren't coal plants still the most economical from a market stand-point

only in the current environment there most of the cost of coal energy (green house gas and other pollutants emissions, environment destruction where coal is mined, etc...) is socialized

Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by marze on Monday August 05, 2013 @03:35PM (#6162389)
Surprisingly, that's not so right now, wind is more cost effective.

The price of a new coal plant in the US has gone up dramatically due to the increases in energy and metals.

Re:Japan nuclear body says radioactive water at Fukushima an... by api on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:32PM (#6162768)
In a free market I doubt we'd have nuclear either.

All energy sources other than fossil fuels are the product of huge government R&D investments and huge subsidies.