News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by tptacek on Monday August 05, 2013 @01:07PM (#6161314)
You don't understand the point I was making, or have seized on a part of the conversation where there's enough ambiguity that it's easy to jump in and generate faux outrage about.

Meanwhile, your comment is yet another instance† of someone not being satisfied that we agree that the program is bad, but instead demanding that we find it bad for exactly the same set of reasons. Again: case in point for why HN is a terrible venue for political discussions.

Incidentally, you might do better than "yes, I see that you claim not to support the program" [em: mine] when in effect admitting that you were not only wrong, but wrong in the entire premise of your response to me.

† https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6160951

Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by graeme on Monday August 05, 2013 @01:39PM (#6161526)
I'm not sure the point you were making was entirely clear. Having read the article, and your replies, I don't see how the original poster misread the article.

It's entirely possible that I don't understand the situation. Could you rephrase the reason you believe the original poster was wrong? i.e. That the evidence trail is public.

Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by tptacek on Monday August 05, 2013 @01:41PM (#6161548)
Again: the "evidence" gleaned from tip-offs from unlawful surveillance can't be introduced into court in any fashion; for instance, it can't be the stated cause of a search, which must still be justified from first-principles by some defensible claim of probable cause.

It's a shadow, secret set of facts, but it isn't evidence and can't be used as such.

And, to be clear: I think the program is bad news and don't support it. But my reasons are probably different from those of many other HN readers, and have more to do with precedent (I think if we're going to do extensive foreign SIGINT --- and, sorry, we just are going to do that --- we should at least firewall it off from domestic law enforcement).

Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by graeme on Monday August 05, 2013 @04:58PM (#6162978)
Suppose we take it to the logical extreme:

1. Monitor absolutely everything 2. Place yourself in the right place 3. Book people for what you're able to stop them for

Isn't there some law or legal doctrine that prevents this sort of police omniscience? Everyone is guilty of some infraction.

In other word, doesn't the law require that police show what led them to stop a person, not that the stop was legal according to one condition.

It seems like the real probable cause is being hidden.

I don't actually know the answer to this, it's a serious question.

Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by betterunix on Monday August 05, 2013 @08:12PM (#6164047)
The police had every reason to stop you: you failed to signal a turn (or you did not come to a complete stop at a stop sign, or you were speeding, or any number of other violations).

The real problem here is that there are far too many laws, which has led to a situation where the police can find a "legitimate" reason to arrest/search anyone. There is also the matter of victimless crimes (like possession of certain drugs), which can turn minor infractions like speeding into 20-year prison sentences. The massive increase in police budgets and power over the past few decades added fuel to the fire, but we were in trouble from the beginning.

Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by fnordfnordfnord on Monday August 05, 2013 @02:28PM (#6161864)
But the point you keep missing is that you're placing trust in an entity which is accountable to no one.
Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by tptacek on Monday August 05, 2013 @02:30PM (#6161880)
No, I haven't done that at all.
Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by dictum on Monday August 05, 2013 @06:55PM (#6163726)
>I think if we're going to do extensive foreign SIGINT --- and, sorry, we just are going to do that --- we should at least firewall it off from domestic law enforcement

A personal question, sorry: legality and constitutionality aside, are you comfortable with ample surveillance of other countries? If so, why? From your posts on HN since the PRISM leaks, you've stressed NSA's mandate to spy on other countries. NSA exists and has this function, yes, but why is it acceptable for the US to spy on all foreigners?

Re:U.S. directs agents to cover up program used to investiga... by tptacek on Monday August 05, 2013 @07:26PM (#6163869)
Yes, I am, for a bunch of reasons, not worth going into here. The simplest response to this would be that broad surveillance of US citizens violates our Constitution, but surveillance of foreigners abroad does not.