Thinking about it again probably it'd be best as a per-repro flag that made a little button appear somewhere saying 'security', 'code police' or something similar, leading to more info. Obviously it'd take a bit of work and generate some false-positives, but I could see a system like this being really handy if they accepted open contributions for filters, even if it was opt-in it would probably still help a lot of people.
Re dirty hacks, I guess I wouldn't publish things like that to github, I'd keep them in a local or private repo, as they're not for sharing. If they are for sharing in spite of vulnerabilities, turning off a warning shouldn't be too much hardship for you, and it could actually help others looking at the code quickly tell it wasn't to be used in production as it would mark it as unsafe.
If someone is encountering the same problem, the code is there for them to use. If they happen to use it in production, that's hardly my fault.
That's where i'm storing my dirty laundry at least...
$ mkdir project_name.git; cd project_name.git; git init --bare
Then locally, from the repo directory:
$ git remote add origin [email protected]:~/path/to/project_name.git
That's what I do (on Webfaction). Of course, then you don't get all the fancy issue tracking and all that from github, but it works if all you need is a few kb of storage for a remote. That also makes it easy to deploy PHP projects with a single post-receive hook, since it's all in the same box.
$ git init --bare project_name.git
It will make the directory for you.
Github should set up a little warning for people when they log in to their account if their repos match any of a set of obvious security anti-patterns, because this would be fertile ground for exploits. They could expand it later to some kind of code-review bot which does automatic code reviews looking for common antipatterns, off-by-one errors, and anything else that is easy to detect automatically. There are quite a few tools like this for analysis of desktop apps, but code for web apps are not checked as much in a systematic way.
Are there any external services which do this already for public github repos?