But in the same half-joking vein, some other problems:
1. I recall reading that such stegonagraphically watermarked videos were pretty easy to detect using simple statistical analysis of the noise in the frames. With dedicated hardware for multimedia decoding cheaply and ubiquitously available, frames can be efficiently extracted and the additional number of bytes does little to slow them down. If the hidden data is encrypted, well, you could just do that without the porn.
2. Unless you make it as easy as tapping a key to start communicating, it still does not remove a main barrier to widespread adoption of encryption, which is inconvenience.
3. The problem with porn is, people will just end up paying more attention to the medium rather than the message.
I think the idea is that it's something people naturally keep hidden, so it doesn't look suspicious to have handed to someone n a USB drive or sent privately. There's not really much suspicious about people hiding porn.
So it is interesting if in reality there is a stego detection tool.
wwwâ.cs.umn.edu/~hopper/tc-stego.pdf
Btw one of the authors is Luis von ahn, the founder of duelingo, the language teaching/translation app.
That's a pretty big if though. I mean, if you miss one nuance the NSA didn't, then your scheme could be toast. At least in the high data limit.
Also, most of the research in the field has been done on black and white image, so it not directly usefull.
And come to think on it, if we're talking about image stego, what prevents the NSA from controlling the statistical distributions of output of cameras in such a way that stego will be noticed(even after some image transforms) ?
It would be easy enough to make a one-click batch process, and would help provide cover noise for real communication channels.
Are you sure you looked hard enough? Most of them include it as very faint morse code somewhere in the icon.
Stenographically-encoded messages in high-def porn. It's secure communications with a built-in subscription model!
Porn accounts for a huge chunk of internet traffic today, and video doesn't compress too well. Get enough people exchanging messages in porn videos and all of a sudden, those listening in have a whole hell of a lot more bytes to sift through.
(I'm only half joking.)