News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Work for Pie is Shutting Down by jack-r-abbit on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:04PM (#6149674)
I've never understood the idea of ranking a developer based on activity on Github, Bitbucket, HN etc. I've been writing code for more than 15 years and don't have a single line of code on an public repo. "Why?", you may ask. Because everything I have done (besides a couple side projects that were never meant for release) has been paid work for an employer/client. Nothing to put in a public repo. And my activity on HN or other boards really has nothing to do with my coding. I'm sure I would score very poorly if I signed up for something like this. So I never would. And that now limits your dev pool to only a certain type of dev... and not necessarily the best ones. So knowing that and looking at it from that angle, if I was looking to hire a dev, I also would not use a site like this. "Why?", you may ask. Because I'd be looking for good devs... not just good devs that happen to release a lot of public code and/or post a lot on HN.
Re:Work for Pie is Shutting Down by bad_user on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:18PM (#6149745)
Nor will you understand it if you keep being a developer that doesn't contribute anything. The idea that you only did paid work for an employer being the reason for why you have no activity on GitHub is a false dichotomy.

Seriously, you never wrote any helpers, or maybe a library that you wanted to reuse across projects?

And in regards to IP, any sane employer would agree that open-sourcing pieces of code that aren't central to the business logic is OK, since if others find it useful, you'll get bug fixes for free.

Re:Work for Pie is Shutting Down by jack-r-abbit on Friday August 02, 2013 @05:28PM (#6149796)
>a developer that doesn't contribute anything

Excuse me? That is rather rude.

Re:Work for Pie is Shutting Down by Greenisus on Friday August 02, 2013 @07:17PM (#6150259)
He means that you don't contribute anything to open source, which is what you said. I don't think the guy was trying to be rude.
Re:Work for Pie is Shutting Down by moocowduckquack on Friday August 02, 2013 @09:36PM (#6150690)
"The idea that you only did paid work for an employer being the reason for why you have no activity on GitHub is a false dichotomy."

Time. Not everyone wants to spend their spare time coding as well as their work time.

"Seriously, you never wrote any helpers, or maybe a library that you wanted to reuse across projects?"

These might be owned by the employer.

"And in regards to IP, any sane employer would agree that open-sourcing pieces of code that aren't central to the business logic is OK"

A minority of employers think like that in my experience.

Re:Work for Pie is Shutting Down by ramchip on Friday August 02, 2013 @07:48PM (#6150355)
A lot of employers are not sane by this definition. I work at a bank and can't release anything, nor do we contribute back our patches to open source projects, because the management/approval/review cost is just so large and everybody's far too busy to do this kind of stuff. Company policy forbids us from posting on forums during working hours anyway.

Unfortunately, I think this is common in finance, and perhaps to a lesser extent in embedded and a lot of other fields.