Re:Senators spar over definition of ‘journalist’ in seeking ...
by rayiner on Friday August 02, 2013 @11:03AM
(#6147328)
There is some additional context that is important here: the bill is intended to create additional protections that aren't already in place, specifically a federal shield law: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shield_laws_in_the_United_State....
Right now, journalists don't have the right to refuse to testify about their sources just as nobody has the right to refuse to testify about anything that isn't covered by the 5th amendment or certain common law privileges. The first amendment protects newspapers from censorship, but does not exempt journalists from the obligation to testify in court about their knowledge, an obligation shared by every other person. Shield laws create a special privilege as an additional layer of protection. Most states have a shield law, but the federal government does not. This bill is an attempt to create one.
As for why there is a need to define journalism or journalists, it's because shield laws cut across a very basic assumption in the legal system: a court can force someone to testify about nearly anything that is relevant. The exceptions are very deeply-rooted ones, like the 5th amendment right to refuse to testify against yourself, spousal privilege (the right to refuse to testify against a spouse), and attorney-client privilege.
It's important to define and cabin the bounds of the privilege, because otherwise anybody could invoke it. Imagine if business partners in a shady dealing could refuse to testify against each other by claiming that one was giving the other legal advice and therefore their conversations were protected by attorney client privilege. Real life isn't CSI, where there is always an orgy of physical evidence. The most basic tool of the court system is being able to get people to testify about what happened, in front of a jury of ordinary people who can judge the credibility of that testimony.
As for why there is a need to define journalism or journalists, it's because shield laws cut across a very basic assumption in the legal system: a court can force someone to testify about nearly anything that is relevant. The exceptions are very deeply-rooted ones, like the 5th amendment right to refuse to testify against yourself, spousal privilege (the right to refuse to testify against a spouse), and attorney-client privilege.
It's important to define and cabin the bounds of the privilege, because otherwise anybody could invoke it. Imagine if business partners in a shady dealing could refuse to testify against each other by claiming that one was giving the other legal advice and therefore their conversations were protected by attorney client privilege. Real life isn't CSI, where there is always an orgy of physical evidence. The most basic tool of the court system is being able to get people to testify about what happened, in front of a jury of ordinary people who can judge the credibility of that testimony.