Re:Bradley Manning and "hacker madness" scare tactic
by RyanMcGreal on Friday August 02, 2013 @08:38AM
(#6146572)
This is surely one of the more bizarre arguments. Does the law draw a distinction between different client applications used to make HTTP requests? Are web browsers somehow privileged because they both fetch resources from web servers and attempt to render them visually in a frame? Is the issue that it's easier to script wget or curl than a browser, so it becomes possible to download more resources more quickly? The argument seems prima facie nonsensical.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Bradley Manning and "hacker madness" scare tactic
by mpyne on Friday August 02, 2013 @10:21AM
(#6147013)
You could make an argument that the government can direct usage of a certain end-user app (which is why I'm sitting here on f'in IE 7 instead of something decent).
However in this case I think it would be more equivalent to charging Manning with using a handtruck to move paper files instead of carrying them one-by-one; i.e. a pretty lame excuse for a charge.
Re:Bradley Manning and "hacker madness" scare tactic
by jaxb on Friday August 02, 2013 @10:57AM
(#6147276)
No, because in a browser you are expected (or forced) to do lots of clicking and double-clicking, and that limits how much info you can access in a given amount of time.
Re:Bradley Manning and "hacker madness" scare tactic
by oakwhiz on Friday August 02, 2013 @11:29AM
(#6147536)
How would download manager browser extensions play into this?
Re:Bradley Manning and "hacker madness" scare tactic
by RyanMcGreal on Friday August 02, 2013 @12:04PM
(#6147774)
Or an external macro script that moves the mouse and clicks stuff?
Seriously, it's a ridiculous distinction and I'm discouraged that a Court would allow it to stand.