News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Buy An Ad, Own a Browser Botnet by corin_ on Thursday August 01, 2013 @04:47PM (#6143416)
Does vetting necessarily help? If I send some JS through for your adops to traffic, and they call code on my own adserver, what's to stop me from altering it after you have trafficked it and it's already live showing to users?

And even if I submit code that is malicious from the start, if it also correctly serves an advert, will you actually notice the extra code if all it's doing is opening a few extra connections?

Maybe you have answers to these questions - I've never worked on an adops side at all, I'm on the buying side, so never had to worry about it.

p.s. Dropped you an email earlier Brad - give me a shout, I really want to try out Perfect Audience!

Re:Buy An Ad, Own a Browser Botnet by dangrossman on Thursday August 01, 2013 @05:34PM (#6143692)
> Does vetting necessarily help? If I send some JS through for your adops to traffic, and they call code on my own adserver, what's to stop me from altering it after you have trafficked it and it's already live showing to users?

You can let your advertisers run JavaScript in ads without letting them inject script tags pointing to external URLs. There's no risk in the script changing if you're only hosting inline code they have no access to after review.

Re:Buy An Ad, Own a Browser Botnet by corin_ on Thursday August 01, 2013 @08:25PM (#6144628)
There's many (perfectly legitimate) buyers out there for whom this would be a deal breaker. If you don't run the adverts through my server (i.e. including using JS on my adserver) then you won't be serving my adverts. And in the world of media buying, that's not at all uncommon.
Re:Buy An Ad, Own a Browser Botnet by rorrr2 on Thursday August 01, 2013 @07:31PM (#6144348)
> let your advertisers run JavaScript in ads without letting them inject script tags pointing to external URLs

How would you do that? That's equivalent to the halting problem. There is an infinite number of ways to assemble code that will execute arbitrary code, which can can assemble code that will execute arbitrary code, which ...

[deleted]
Re:Buy An Ad, Own a Browser Botnet by rorrr2 on Thursday August 01, 2013 @07:48PM (#6144439)
It means that every piece of the code must be examined by a human. That's expensive.
Re:Buy An Ad, Own a Browser Botnet by brandnewlow on Thursday August 01, 2013 @07:11PM (#6144248)
D'oh! Just wrote you back. My bad.

So the vetting we do is somewhat extreme. We ask you to sign on as an enterprise customer to run ads like that. Making things more official tends to weed people out pretty quickly and leaves us just the well-intending players.