News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Regarding the ITC's exclusion order against Apple by hga on Thursday August 01, 2013 @09:12AM (#6140019)
Nothing in this article implies that Samsung wouldn't be willing to do a deal in cash with such a no/not enough patents company.

For that matter, did Apple make a cash counteroffer?

Re:Regarding the ITC's exclusion order against Apple by sgift on Thursday August 01, 2013 @09:23AM (#6140092)
Not stated, but if I read the article correctly Samsung made a money or patent offer:

"Notably, the Commission dismissed Apple’s arguments that (1) Samsung’s initial offer was so high as to show bad faith, and (2) Samsung’s attempts to get a cross-license to Apple’s non-SEPs violated its FRAND commitments."

This reads to me like they offered Apple an cash deal and an alternative patent deal. Sounds fair to me.

Re:Regarding the ITC's exclusion order against Apple by josephlord on Thursday August 01, 2013 @11:39AM (#6141029)
Firstly the article explicitly stated the authors belief that it could be FRAND and I disagree with that. Really that is probably the fundamental area for disagreement in these FRAND cases and can be debated without reference to a particular case (and having to get into a detailed who did and said what session).

Secondly I'm not sure that there is much dispute that any cash deal offered was probably beyond the bounds of reasonableness.

I fear the ITC wants to be relevant so it is using the only sanction it has (import bans) despite the inappropriateness in the case of FRAND patents.