News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who is the Villain in this Disruption Story? by mikeash on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @08:00PM (#6137696)
I can't feel sympathetic at all to the idea that this car rental company should somehow avoid these fees.

This is not a story of potentially overbearing or obsolete regulation such as that faced by companies like Uber and Airbnb. This is simply a property owner controlling activity on their own property. The fact that airports are usually owned my governments is completely incidental here. You'd no doubt find the same sort of fees at a privately-owned airport. If you want to do business on somebody else's property, you play by the owner's rules, end of story.

Re:Who is the Villain in this Disruption Story? by fitandfunction on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @08:24PM (#6137803)
Agreed.

The obvious move for FlightCar is to partner with nearby garages, and offer a valet service to drive passengers to their terminals. To sweeten the deal, FlightCar might offer to wash or do basic maintenance (oil change) on the car for an added fee.

The passenger gets

  - convenience of getting dropped off at terminals (vs. walking from airport parking)
  - convenience of taking advantage of car "dead time" to get cleaned / serviced
  - some money (from the rental), to boot
Re:Who is the Villain in this Disruption Story? by gojomo on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @09:26PM (#6138039)
That's already what FlightCar is doing: their facilities are all off-airport, in another city 5 minutes away.

The valet drop-off/pick-up service (and air-travel-related marketing) is what SFO thinks entitles them to the rental agency fees... even though the drop-off/pick-up is indistingushable, in terms of impact, from having a friend drive you.

Re:Who is the Villain in this Disruption Story? by gojomo on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @09:24PM (#6138031)
A private company couldn't write tickets, and likely couldn't discriminate against private cars that just happen to be hired (but otherwise indistinguishable from the private cars delivering other customers).

SFO has been granted a monopoly on land, waterfront, and airspace by several levels of government, and is owned by the public, so this reductionist "the owner can do as they damn well please, social welfare be damned" analysis doesn't apply.

Re:Who is the Villain in this Disruption Story? by redthrowaway on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @08:17PM (#6137771)
Yeah, I think this is a great idea, but they should pay the damned airport fees. They derive exactly the same benefits from the airports being there that traditional car rental companies do, so they should shut up and pay the piper.
Re:Who is the Villain in this Disruption Story? by gojomo on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @09:34PM (#6138069)
Actually, they don't derive the same benefits. They have no cars or counter on-site.

Also, it's likely a majority of their drop-offs and pick-ups aren't even people renting cars! Instead, they're locals, who've dropped off their car at a remote lot for maybe-renting. Why should such a person be routed out through the remote rental-counter-center, when they're not a car-renter? They're most like any other local arriving via cab or limo, so that's the airport-usage-fee that should apply.

Re:Who is the Villain in this Disruption Story? by AsymetricCom on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @08:49PM (#6137895)
I hate how they default to a completely out of scope argument: but we're providing a valuable service by putting unused cars to work. No, you're providing yourself with paychecks. The operations of your business are only a subset of that.

It's the same kind of un-scoped reason that leads to conclusions like trickle down theory. They think because they're proving a service that someone can presumably benefit from, that gives them a blank check to consume as much as they can to provide that service, thus completely negating the positive impact of their business through crock-pot philosophy. Obviously, there is no sound logic in this line of reasoning. Obviously, they're not going to argue that they should pay more since they don't have a fleet to maintain. "Invisible" hand?

The solution is quite simple really: there is no simple solution. If you're going to displace a business you can't replace them with something less then what they were and expect to make more money than they did, at least not in a sustainable way. It's simple thermal dynamics.

This is all a subset of issues born of cargo-cult thinking, techy buzz words and such that give businesses respect they simply co-opted by using the word/technology in marketing materials. More bubbles, more start up trends, more 'combinators separating uninformed people and their money without providing real value and expecting to get their @#$% &*!! for doing us the favor.