Re:FISA court judge: No company has ever challenged Patriot ...
by DannyBee on Wednesday July 31, 2013 @02:44PM
(#6135960)
Your entire argument is basically "current rules require it for preserving on appeal". Sure. If the FRCP/FRAP/etc didn't require that, can you think of another reason?
We aren't talking about opinions, or motions to decide the case of various forms that will produce such opinions, but just every day motions on requests for production or whatever (which is what FISC is dealing with).
I mean, this is in fact, the whole point of things like magistrate judges.
Yes, they would, because the interests of the parties, and the law, are often wildly at odds, and even when they know the judge will deny a motion, a party will often want to raise it because raising certain issues are important if you believe the judge is wrong and want to raise issues on appeal.
A court that does not deny motions is ridiculous on the face of it. It's pretty much unheard of outside of banana republic dictatorships.