That's all I said. I'm not saying nobody should trust them. I'm not saying they aren't trustworthy in general.
I just said that I don't trust them with my phone number (or gmail HOTP secret for that matter).
Especially in matters of authentication services that require more private information than what's strictly needed leave a bad taste in my mouth.
Never quite understood the HN fetishism about keeping emails and phone numbers private. I hand them out like candy and haven't felt a price for it.
Also, my phone number is known to some identity providers I trust. If they sent me an SMS asking me to click a link, I might be inclined to follow that link. This is quite right despite the sender being very easily spoofable because nobody but these identity providers know my phone number.
No. I'd rather be very careful with that number.
Of course you could be phished or tricked by SMS but to expect your number to be private is to expect everyone ever who you give the number to go to extreme to keep it private as well.
If you ever gave your number to someone who downloaded an app which has permission to contacts your number is no longer private (Facebook has taken big advantage of this, I'm sure there are less than reliable apps that took bigger advantage).
It's not hard to pluck SMS out of the air and sooner rather than later that's going to be a new attack.
Great one more thing to worry about.
Sorry for being cynical, but judging from all these services coming and going all over the place, any of the following is going to happen within a year: 1) authy gets bought by $COMPANY. With some likelihood it's not a company I want to have my phone number. 2) authy runs out of money and needs a revenue stream. Thus it changes the TOS and starts selling phone numbers. 3) authy shuts down. Who knows what's going to happen with my phone number then.
No. I'd rather use any other HOTP app that doesn't require any personal data (which is one of the basic ideas behind HOTP).
Authentication and my phone number are the two things you have to really prove you have got your act together before I trust you with them.